Abstract:Solving clinical problems requires an individual to apply not only domain-specific medical knowledge and cognitive skills for reasoning, but also to be consciously aware of, monitor, and evaluate their thinking processes (i.e., metacognition). The purpose of this study was to map critical metacognitive dimensions of clinical problem solving and to explore the structural relationships among them, which may help frame a conceptual framework and better pedagogy for effective intervention. A context-specific inventory was adapted and modified from a domain-general instrument to capture essential metacognitive skills for learning and solving clinical problems. This inventory was administered to 72 undergraduate medical students to survey their capabilities in five dimensions: knowledge of cognition, objectives, problem representation, monitoring, and evaluation. The interplay among these dimensions was further examined using partial least squares structural equation modeling. Our findings revealed that the medical students fell short of some expert-like, metacognitive, and regulatory competence, even after receiving years of medical education and on-site training. In particular, they did not know when a holistic understanding of a problem had been reached. Many of them often do not have a set of clear diagnostic procedures in mind, nor do they concurrently monitor their thinking during diagnostic reasoning. Moreover, their lack of self-improving approaches seemed to worsen their learning. Finally, the structural equation model indicated that knowledge of cognition and objectives significantly predicted problem representation, suggesting that medical learners' knowledge of and goals for learning are influential in framing the clinical problems at hand. A significant linear prediction path was observed from problem representation, monitoring, to evaluation, signifying a possible sequenced process of clinical problem solving. Metacognitive-based instruction can help improve clinical problem-solving skills and awareness of potential biases or errors.

Cultivating clinical decision-making ability in the view of tacit knowledge

Scientific Clinic Thinking and Clinic Decision

Tacit Knowledge Research:Emerging Achievements,Current Dilemmas,and Future Directions

Integrating HL7 RIM and Ontology for Unified Knowledge and Data Representation in Clinical Decision Support Systems

Tacit knowledge and the cultivation of medical students' vocational ability

Mobilizing Clinical Decision Support to Facilitate Knowledge Translation: a Case Study in China.

Nurture and Improvement of Scientific Research Ability in Medical Professionals Based on Tacit Knowledge Construction

Training on Clinical Thinking to Improve Clinicians' Skills of Disease Diagnosis and Management

Cultivating Countermeasures on Hospital High - quality Talents： tacit knowledge perspective

Empirical Study on Influence of Implicit Knowledge of Clinicians'Values on Their Work Performance

Time-series dynamic three-way group decision-making model and its application in TCM efficacy evaluation

Research on teaching methods of video-assisted thoracic surgery in the view of tacit knowledge

Discussion of the cultivation clinical thinking ability for the medical students through application of the case-based teaching method

Clinical ability culture of medical students in surgical teaching

Tacit knowledge in medical consultations for patients with profound intellectual and multiple disabilities: An exploratory qualitative study

Training Medical Students' Critical Thinking in Clinical Practice

Clinical Decision-making:the process of communication and cooperation of doctor and patient

Tacit Knowledge: an Epistemological Interpretation of Incomplete Verbal Expression

Clinical Decision-Making by the Emergency Department Resident Physicians for Critically Ill Patients

Exploring medical students' metacognitive and regulatory dimensions of diagnostic problem solving

Complex decision making in an intensive care environment: Perceived practice versus observed reality