A study of pre- and post-perception comparisons and evaluation of satisfaction and influencing factors among physicians with pediatric and adolescent gynecology subspecialty training in China
Yuchen Zhang,Liying Sun,Yuchen Zhang,Jiayu Du,Huihui Gao,Peige Song,Changzheng Yuan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpag.2023.01.186
IF: 2.046
2023-01-01
Journal of Pediatric and Adolescent Gynecology
Abstract:Study ObjectiveThe target population of this study were the participants who received continuing education in pediatric and adolescent gynecology (PAG) carried out at the Children's Hospital of Zhejiang University School of Medicine (ZJUCH). We aimed to understand their satisfaction with the whole process and to explore the factors that might affect satisfaction.Materials and MethodsBefore the survey, we obtained information about the participants in the PAG training program from ZJUCH. The online questionnaire collected 125 responses from 21 provinces. Survey indicators include: (1) demographic characteristics and socio-economic status: gender, age, education, etc.; (2) hospital information: property, type, nature of the unit, hospital grade, etc.; (3) pre-training information: knowledge of PAG, perceived importance, intention to participate in program and whether have participated in other PAG-related training; (4) training effect assessment: training learning, training content recognition, training satisfaction, willingness to continue learning.ResultsOf the 125 participating physicians, the mean overall satisfaction score was 8.93 (on a 10-point scale) .106 approved of the training and 116 expressed an overall satisfaction rating greater than 5. Most said that they did not know or knew a little about PAG before training (Figure1). After training, they knew very well about the four major aspects of PAG, namely, its difference and connection with obstetrics and gynecology and pediatrics, its main disease spectrum, main treatment and surgical protocols. This indicates that the training works at the level of enhancing cognition (Figure2). Furthermore, they would use the knowledge in clinical practice and participate in follow-up training and clinical research projects, but nearly half of them were unsure or unwilling to become a PAG specialist.There was a statistical difference in satisfaction among the 19 characteristics such as gender, education, hospital level and so on (Table 1).A dichotomous logistic regression analysis (Table 2) showed that wanting to get involved in the project, high satisfaction with the occupation and workload, and knowledge of the differences after training were positive factors influencing the satisfaction.ConclusionsWe found that the PAG training was effective, with high satisfaction, and a great benefit to daily clinic. However, some problems were revealed: the training format, content, and assessment forms need to be further improved, the willingness to become a PAG specialist is low, the training is rarely conducted in China, and the social support for this field is insufficient.This study was approved by the Medical Ethics Committee, School of Public Health, Zhejiang University (project number: ZGL202101-9), and all participants provided informed consent. I confirm that all methods performed were in accordance with relevant guidelines and regulations.Figure 1 Perception of the PAG field before the training A Level of knowledge of the PAG field before training B Perceived importance of the PAG field before trainingFigure 2 Self-assessment of post-training learningAdditional Figure1 Geographical distribution map The target population of this study were the participants who received continuing education in pediatric and adolescent gynecology (PAG) carried out at the Children's Hospital of Zhejiang University School of Medicine (ZJUCH). We aimed to understand their satisfaction with the whole process and to explore the factors that might affect satisfaction. Before the survey, we obtained information about the participants in the PAG training program from ZJUCH. The online questionnaire collected 125 responses from 21 provinces. Survey indicators include: (1) demographic characteristics and socio-economic status: gender, age, education, etc.; (2) hospital information: property, type, nature of the unit, hospital grade, etc.; (3) pre-training information: knowledge of PAG, perceived importance, intention to participate in program and whether have participated in other PAG-related training; (4) training effect assessment: training learning, training content recognition, training satisfaction, willingness to continue learning. Of the 125 participating physicians, the mean overall satisfaction score was 8.93 (on a 10-point scale) .106 approved of the training and 116 expressed an overall satisfaction rating greater than 5. Most said that they did not know or knew a little about PAG before training (Figure1). After training, they knew very well about the four major aspects of PAG, namely, its difference and connection with obstetrics and gynecology and pediatrics, its main disease spectrum, main treatment and surgical protocols. This indicates that the training works at the level of enhancing cognition (Figure2). Furthermore, they would use the knowledge in clinical practice and participate in follow-up training and clinical research projects, but nearly half of them were unsure or unwilling to become a PAG specialist. There was a statistical difference in satisfaction among the 19 characteristics such as gender, education, hospital level and so on (Table 1). A dichotomous logistic regression analysis (Table 2) showed that wanting to get involved in the project, high satisfaction with the occupation and workload, and knowledge of the differences after training were positive factors influencing the satisfaction. We found that the PAG training was effective, with high satisfaction, and a great benefit to daily clinic. However, some problems were revealed: the training format, content, and assessment forms need to be further improved, the willingness to become a PAG specialist is low, the training is rarely conducted in China, and the social support for this field is insufficient.