Abstract:Background: The medical performance evaluation, which provides a basis for rational decision-making, is an important part of medical service research. Current progress with health services reform in China is far from satisfactory, without sufficient regulation. To achieve better progress, an effective tool for evaluating medical performance needs to be established. In view of this, this study attempted to develop such a tool appropriate for the Chinese context.Methods: Data was collected from the front pages of medical records (FPMR) of all large general public hospitals (21 hospitals) in the third and fourth quarter of 2007. Locally developed Diagnosis Related Groups (DRGs) were introduced as a tool for risk adjustment and performance evaluation indicators were established: Charge Efficiency Index (CEI), Time Efficiency Index (TEI) and inpatient mortality of low-risk group cases (IMLRG), to reflect respectively work efficiency and medical service quality. Using these indicators, the inpatient services' performance was horizontally compared among hospitals. Case-mix Index (CMI) was used to adjust efficiency indices and then produce adjusted CEI (aCEI) and adjusted TEI (aTEI). Poisson distribution analysis was used to test the statistical significance of the IMLRG differences between different hospitals.Results: Using the aCEI, aTEI and IMLRG scores for the 21 hospitals, Hospital A and C had relatively good overall performance because their medical charges were lower, LOS shorter and IMLRG smaller. The performance of Hospital P and Q was the worst due to their relatively high charge level, long LOS and high IMLRG. Various performance problems also existed in the other hospitals.Conclusion: It is possible to develop an accurate and easy to run performance evaluation system using Case-Mix as the tool for risk adjustment, choosing indicators close to consumers and managers, and utilizing routine report forms as the basic information source. To keep such a system running effectively, it is necessary to improve the reliability of clinical information and the risk-adjustment ability of Case-Mix.

Design and Application of Performance Appraisal Program at Clinical Departments Based on the Concept of Value Transfer

Establishment of an indexing system for performance management and appraisal in military hospitals

Design and realization of performance management and appraisal system for military hospitals

Practice and Experience of the Score System in Promotions Made by the Hospital

Establishment of Head Nurses ' Performance Appraisal Indicators System in Clinical Departments of 3- Level Hospitals

Practice of promoting high-quality development in a children′s hospital using public hospital performance appraisal as a key point

Performance evaluation of township hospitals in Guangzhou area

Performance Evaluation of Inpatient Service in Beijing: a Horizontal Comparison with Risk Adjustment Based on Diagnosis Related Groups

Establishment and application of performance appraisal scoring system for medical research in hospital

Research on the Application and Evaluation of the Performance Appraisal System to Clinical Medical Technology Departments

Practice and Thought of Performance Assessment Based on Methods of Resource Based Relative Value Scale and Key Performance Indicator

The implementation of performance evaluation and management for nurses

Practice of the Reform of Performance Appraisal and the Income Allocation System of Public Hospitals in Shanghai

Selection and Design of the Performance Appraisal Indicators of Hospital Clinical Pharmacists

Reform and Explorations on Appraisal and Incentives Mechanism for Senior Medical Professionals at Hospitals

Established path and effect appraise for index system of performance assessment to hospital administrative departments

The exploration and practice of Shanghai municipal hospital internal performance assessment and salary system

Employment of 360-Degree Evaluation and Performance Report Evaluation

Analysis of the main problems and countermeasures in the performance appraisal of tertiary public hospitals in China

The development and application of a phased 360-degree performance appraisal feedback system for operating room nurses

Practice of Performance Appraisal for Directors of Shanghai Public Hospitals