Abstract:Abstract Background Research achievement is essential for promotion in most Chinese medical institutions, causing enormous pressure among clinicians. We believe ours is the first nationwide questionnaire survey about cliniciansu0027 attitude to the current title promotion system. The aim of this study is to investigate the present title promotion mechanism and put forward policy recommendations. Methods We surveyed doctors from regions with different economic development, from a variety of geographical locations, with different degrees of professional title, and working at different levels of hospital in 31 districts in China. Clinicians completed a 29-item survey which included questions about demographic characteristics, work conditions, promotion conditions, the existing promotion system, and suggestions for reform. We used descriptive analysis to compile our findings. The Chinese Academy of Engineering Ethics Committee reviewed the protocol and exempted it from additional ethical approval. Findings 7020 questionnaires were sent out and 6953 were analysed. 85·8% (5965/6953) of respondents are under great pressure, primarily from desire for promotion (4915 [70·7%]). Much less pressure was reported from doctor–patient tensions (4638/6953 [66·7%]) or work demands (4460 [64·1%]). 67·3% (4678/6953) of respondents reported research achievement was decisive for promotion, while working performance was reported as decisive by 38·8% (2699). 92·2% (6414/6953) reported a belief that the current system for promotion is problematic and 83·7% (5823) that the most important problem is excessive emphasis on research accomplishment. 88·5% (6150/6953) reported that working performance is unduly ignored for promotion. 77·6% (5394/6953) reported having seen people resort to improper means to achieve promotion, and 43·8% (3044) would consider using illicit means themselves. 79·3% (5516/6953) suggested the characteristics of each class of hospital be accommodated in any reform, and 72·9% (5071) suggested that title appraisal should be associated with clinical performance. Interpretation Doctors should be encouraged to pursue research. However, the current appraisal system with a focus on scientific publication and low emphasis on clinical practice has put burdens onto clinicians and our results suggest this system could lead to academic misconduct. A new appraisal system that takes into account working performance, professional skills, and innovation capacity should be established. For doctors working in community and rural areas, the new system should take limited account of innovation capacity. The survey was limited by the huge number and variety of classifications of clinicians. Funding Chinese Academy of Engineering (2014-ZD-09)

Practice and Experience of the Score System in Promotions Made by the Hospital

Practice of promoting high-quality development in a children′s hospital using public hospital performance appraisal as a key point

Performance evaluation of township hospitals in Guangzhou area

Practice and Lessons Learnt from Building The“surgeon Qualification Admittance System”

Establishment and application of performance appraisal scoring system for medical research in hospital

Reform and Explorations on Appraisal and Incentives Mechanism for Senior Medical Professionals at Hospitals

Practice of the Reform of Performance Appraisal and the Income Allocation System of Public Hospitals in Shanghai

Professional title promotion among clinicians: a cross-sectional survey.

Exploration on index system of physician performance assessment in a tertiary hospital in Shanghai

Design and Application of Performance Appraisal Program at Clinical Departments Based on the Concept of Value Transfer

Strategy of physician performance appraisal based on appraisers,competition,and information

Practice of Performance Appraisal for Directors of Shanghai Public Hospitals

Practice and Thought of Performance Assessment Based on Methods of Resource Based Relative Value Scale and Key Performance Indicator

The exploration and practice of Shanghai municipal hospital internal performance assessment and salary system

Selection and Design of the Performance Appraisal Indicators of Hospital Clinical Pharmacists

Analysis of community health services related to individual-performance appraisal index

Study on Indicators and Evaluation of Nurses' Performance Appraisal

Practice and Reflection on Performance Appraisal of Administration Stuff in a Public Hospital in Wuhan Based on 360-Degree-feedback Appraisal

Establishment of Comprehensive Capability Evaluation System for Outstanding Young Talents in Certain Three-grade First-Level Hospital

APPRAISAL SYSTEM FOR NURSES IN BINGZHOU TERTIARY PUBLIC HOSPITAL: BASIS FOR STRENGTHENING THE PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM

Analysis on the results of physician performance assessment in a top tertiary public hospital of Shanghai