A Comparative Study on Quality of Life Assessed with SF-36 in Adolescents with Epilepsy and Asthma
王佶,徐慧,王艺,张晓蕾
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-5501.2009.03.009
2009-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the quality of life (QOL) in adolescents with epilepsy and asthma using SF-36 scale(the medical outcomes study 36-item short-form health survey).Methods QOL of children with epilepsy (n=85), healthy children (n=87) and children with asthma (n=81) (matched with sex, age and level of education) as control followed up in the outpatients of Children′s Hospital of Fudan University were evaluated. These children respectively received survey in neurologist outpatients, child health care outpatients and respirologist outpatients. SF-36 scale was included in QOL assessment.Results Reliability and validity of SF-36 scale were retested. The Kappa of reliability and validity test was 0.87 and 0.86. All the children had no difference in family population and family income (P0.05). The ages of children were 14-18 years old, the average age was [(15.6-15.7)±1.3] years old. There was no difference in onset age, disease course and the frequency of attacks between epilepsy group and asthma group (P0.05). 70 epilepsy patients and 59 asthma patients received one kind of drug. 63 epilepsy patients and 56 asthma patients never forgot the medication. There was no difference in the number of drug and medication compliance between two groups(P0.05). 36 epilepsy patients were seizure free lasting more than one year,other 79 patients were out of control.29 asthma patients were without acute attack, the largest peak expiratory flow (PEF) always kept above 80%, other 52 asthma patients were active. The QOL of children with epilepsy was lower than that of healthy children, including total score(Z=-5.123,P0.01) and other eight items(physical functioning, role physical, bodily pain, general health, vitality, social functioning, role emotional, mental health ) (Z=-4.459, -3.253, -2.877, -5.150, -4.311, -3.283, -3.604, -4.351, P0.01), and much more serious than that of children with asthma in total score(Z=3.600,P0.01) and other four items(physical functioning, bodily pain, general health, vitality) (Z=-5.382, -2.667, -4.416, -3.087, P0.01). The QOL of children with asthma was lower than that of healthy children, including total score(Z=-3.600,P0.01) and other four items(physical functioning, bodily pain, general health, vitality ) (Z= -5.382, -2.667, -4.416, -3.087, P0.01). The QOL of children with epilepsy under control was lower than that of children with asthma under control in total score(Z=-6.118,P0.01) and other six items (role physical, social functioning, role emotional, mental health, general health, vitality) (Z=-4.048,-3.019, -5.588, -4.756, P0.01; Z=-2.976, -1.972, P0.05). The QOL of children with epilepsy out of control was poorer than that of children with asthma out of control in total score(Z=-4.914,P0.01) and other five items (physical functioning, general health, role emotional, mental health, social functioning) (Z=-2.627, -3.152, -4.026, -3.664, P0.01; Z=-2.340, P0.05). The emotion function and mental health in epilepsy group were much poorer than those in asthma group. Psychological barriers in children with epilepsy were persistent regardless the seizure frequency. Conclusions The QOL of children with epilepsy and asthma was obviously poorer than that of healthy children. The QOL of children with epilepsy was damaged much more seriously than that of children with asthma. SF-36 scale can evaluate the QOL of chronic paroxysmal disorders such as epilepsy and asthma. SF-36 scale can be used as a means of the degree of disease control, auxiliary evaluation of the efficacy of the treatment of disease. Besides reasonable usage of medications, comprehensive management including psychological intervention should be applied to children with epilepsy to improve the social function and QOL.