A Multicenter Prospective Evaluation of Four Enhanced Magnifying Endoscopy for Diagnosis of Precancerous Lesions and Early Gastric Cancers

于航,杨爱明,陆星华,周炜洵,郭涛,舒慧君,姚礼庆,何利平,王邦茂
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1007-5232.2015.07.001
2015-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of four enhanced magnifying endoscopy methods for precancerous lesions and early gastric cancers,i.e.,magnifying endoscopy enhanced by epinephrine(ME-EPI),magnifying endoscopy enhanced by acetic acid-indigo carmine mixture (ME-AIM),magnifying endoscopy enhanced by indigo carmine(ME-IDC) and magnifying endoscopy enhanced with narrow-band imaging(ME-NBI).Methods A total of 3 059 patients (3 097 focal gastric lesions) detected with conventional white light endoscopy(WLE) at four hospitals from January 2010 to December 2011 were recruited and divided into three groups according to different chromoendoscopic procedures they underwent:1 094 ME-EPI cases,873 ME-AIM cases and 1 130 ME-IDC cases.The pathological results were used as golden standard,and diagnosis accuracy rates of precancerous lesions or early cancers were determined according to the VS criteria.At the mean time,in each group,a paired design was used to compare the accuracy between the above chromoendoscopies and ME-NBI respectively.Results A total of 3 097 lesions of 3 059 patients were evaluated,and 205 lesions were diagnosed as early gastric cancer according to pathological results.The diagnostic accuracy rates of ME-EPI,ME-AIM and ME-IDC for early gastric cancer were 98.2%,99.0% and 98.4%,respectively.In each group,the diagnostic accuracy rates of paired ME-NBI were 98.0%,99.0% and 97.4%,respectively.In contrast to ME-NBI,the diagnostic accuracy of ME-EPI and ME-AIM were comparable or lower,but the differences were not statistically significant (P > 0.05).However,when it came to ME-IDC,the diagnostic accuracy declined and the differences were statistically significant (P < 0.05).Conclusion Chromoendoscopy can be used to identify the early gastric cancer accurately,easily,safely and inexpensively.And the diagnostic effectiveness of ME-NBI is not superior to chromoendoscopy in diagnosing early gastric cancer.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?