Effectiveness Evaluation of the National Community Nursing Teacher Training Based on Kirkpatrick Model
Wei JIA,Ya-ping DU
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.01.017
2018-01-01
Chinese General Practice
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the effectiveness of the national community nursing teacher training based on Kirkpatrick model.Methods We conducted a questionnaire survey in three groups (2011 group 39 cases, 2014 group 34 cases and 2016 group 35 cases) of selected trainees (totaled 117 cases) with the experience of attending the national community nursing teacher training held in Zhejiang General Practice Training Center in 2011, 2014 or 2016. The survey achieved a response rate of 92.3％ (108/117). And a Kirkpatrick model was used to evaluate the effectiveness of the training from the aspects of reaction, learning, behavior and results.Results Overall, 24 (61.5％) trainees in 2011 group, 26 (76.5％) trainees in 2014 group , and 29 (82.9％) trainees in 2016 group were very satisfied with this training. The levels of satisfaction with training goals, teaching methods or trainers differed significantly between the three groups of trainees (P<0.05), while the overall assessment of the training, level of satisfaction with teaching contents, training hours, training materials or examination forms did not (P>0.05). The assessment of the training's role in the improvement of scientific research capabilities varied significantly between the three groups (P<0.05), but its role in the improvement of professional competence, teaching capability, promotion of the position and professional and technical title did not (P>0.05). The percentage of trainees undertaking community nursing education,organizing or participating in community nursing teaching differed substantially between the groups (P<0.05), whereas that of trainees organizing the development of community nursing discipline or conducted the development of excellent courses related to community nursing did not (P>0.05). The total number of trainees who were involved in on-the-job community nurse training was 61 (56.5％), including 31 (79.5％) in 2011 group, 16 (47.1％) in 2014 group,and 14 (40.0％) in 2016 group. The total number of trainees who served as a training teacher for local on-the-job community nurse training was 23 (37.7％), including 11 (28.2％) in 2011 group,8 (23.5％) in 2014 group,and 4 (11.4％) in 2016 group.Conclusion The trainings achieved good effects and high level of trainees' satisfaction. The training improved the trainees' scientific research capability about community nursing. However, when trainees went back to work, they made little contribution to the local community nursing teaching.