Comment on “influence of a Basic Intrusion on the Vitrinite Reflectance and Chemistry of the Springfield (no. 5) Coal, Harrisburg, Illinois” by Stewart Et Al. (2005)

Dayong Wang,Xiancai Lu,Shijin Xu,Wenxuan Hu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.coal.2007.03.004
IF: 6.3
2007-01-01
International Journal of Coal Geology
Abstract:In this communication, we demonstrate that the intrusion temperature of about 600 degrees C for the Cottage Grove dike provided by Stewart et al. [Stewart, A.K., Massey, M., Padgett, P.L., Rimmer, S.M., Hower, J.C., 2005. Influence of a basic intrusion on the vitrinite reflectance and chemistry of the Springfield (No. 5) coal, Harrisburg, Illinois. International Journal of Coal Geology 63, 58-67] is questionable, because their computation is based on an unrealistic heat flow model and the estimated contact temperature is derived from a geothermometer that is not calibrated for contact metamorphism. In order to obtain an accurate and reliable intrusion temperature based on the contact temperature of the intrusion, a reliable geothermometer in high temperature ranges should be used to calculate the peak temperature. (C) 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?