Abstract:In the context of Concentrated Solar Power (CSP) technology, this paper presents a comparison between the Parabolic Trough Collector (PTC) and the Linear Fresnel Collector (LFC), considering both evacuated and non-evacuated receiver tubes. The comparison was carried out in terms of the Levelized Cost of Electricity (LCOE) considering a reference year and four locations in the world, characterized by different levels of direct normal irradiation (DNI) from 2183 kWh/m2/year to 3409 kWh/m2/year. The LCOE depends on economic parameters and on the net energy generated by a plant on an annual basis. The latter was determined by a steady-state 1D model that solved the energy balance along the receiver axis. This model required computing the incident solar power and heat losses. While the solar power was calculated by an optical ray-tracing model, heat losses were computed by a lumped-parameter model developed along the radial direction of the tube. Since the LFC adopted a secondary concentrator, no conventional correlation was applicable for the convective heat transfer from the glass cover to the environment. Therefore, a 2D steady-state CFD model was also developed to investigate this phenomenon. The results showed that the PTC could generate a higher net annual energy compared to the LFC due to a better optical performance ensured by the parabolic solar collector. Nevertheless, the difference between the PTC and the LFC was lower in the non-evacuated tubes because of lower heat losses from the LFC receiver tube. The economic analysis revealed that the PTC with the evacuated tube also achieved the lowest LCOE, since the higher cost with respect to both the LFC system and the non-evacuated PTC was compensated by the higher net energy yield. However, the non-evacuated LFC demonstrated a slightly lower LCOE compared to the non-evacuated PTC since the lower capital cost of the non-evacuated LFC outweighed its lower net annual energy yield. Finally, a sensitivity analysis was conducted to assess the impact on the LCOE of the annual optical efficiency and of the economic parameters. This study introduces key technical parameters in LFC technology requiring improvement to achieve the level of productivity of the PTC from a techno-economic viewpoint, and consequently, to fill the gap between the two technologies.

Comprehensive Review of Line-Focus Concentrating Solar Thermal Technologies: Parabolic Trough Collector (PTC) vs Linear Fresnel Reflector (LFR)

Progress in Concentrated Solar Power Technology with Parabolic Trough Collector System: A Comprehensive Review

Comparative Techno-Economic Analysis of Parabolic Trough and Linear Fresnel Collectors with Evacuated and Non-Evacuated Receiver Tubes in Different Geographical Regions

A Detailed Parameter Study on the Comprehensive Characteristics and Performance of a Parabolic Trough Solar Collector System

Comprehensive Assessment of Line-/Point-focus Combined Scheme for Concentrating Solar Power System

Review of Concentrated Solar Power Technology Applications in Photocatalytic Water Purification and Energy Conversion: Overview, Challenges and Future Directions

Theoretical and Experimental Study on Solar Thermal Mechanism of A Point-Line-Coupling-Focus System Employing Linear Fresnel Reflector

Concentrated solar energy applications using Fresnel lenses: A review

A review on the recent research progress in the compound parabolic concentrator (CPC) for solar energy applications

A Review of the Compound Parabolic Concentrator (CPC) with a Tubular Absorber

An On-Site Test Method for Thermal and Optical Performances of Parabolic-Trough Loop for Utility-Scale Concentrating Solar Power Plant

Thermal performance investigation of the newly shaped vacuum tubes of parabolic trough collector system

Heat loss analysis review: Parabolic trough and linear Fresnel collectors

Comparative Study on Two Photovoltaic and Thermal Solar Moduleds with Point-Focus Fresnel Concentrator

Design and thermodynamic analysis of an innovative parabolic trough photovoltaic/thermal system with film-based beam splitter

A Detailed Study on the Optical Performance of Parabolic Trough Solar Collectors with Monte Carlo Ray Tracing Method Based on Theoretical Analysis

Experimental study of a linear Fresnel reflection solar concentrating system

Experimental and optical performances of a solar CPV device using a linear Fresnel reflector concentrator

A mutually beneficial system incorporating parabolic trough concentrating solar power system with photovoltaics: A comprehensive techno-economic analysis

Trough-Type Free-Form Secondary Solar Concentrator for CPV/T Application

Optical performance investigation on flat receiver for parabolic trough solar collector based on the MCRT method