Abstract:Understanding change in forest carbon (C) is important for devising strategies to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases. National forest inventories (NFIs) are important to meet international accounting goals, but data are often incomplete going back in time, and the amount of time between remeasurements can make attribution of C flux to specific events difficult. The long time series of Landsat imagery provides spatially comprehensive, consistent information that can be used to fill the gaps in ground measurements with predictive models. To evaluate such models, we relate Landsat spectral changes and disturbance interpretations directly to C flux measured on NFI plots and compare the performance of models with and without ground-measured predictor variables. The study was conducted in the forests of southwest Oregon State, USA, a region of diverse forest types, disturbances, and landowner management objectives. Plot data consisted of 676 NFI plots with remeasured individual tree data over a mean interval (time 1 to time 2) of 10.0 years. We calculated change in live aboveground woody carbon (AWC), including separate components of growth, mortality, and harvest. We interpreted radiometrically corrected annual Landsat images with the TimeSync (TS) tool for a 90 m × 90 m area over each plot. Spectral time series were divided into segments of similar trajectories and classified as disturbance, recovery, or stability segments, with type of disturbance identified. We calculated a variety of values and segment changes from tasseled cap angle and distance (TCA and TCD) as potential predictor variables of C flux. Multiple linear regression was used to model AWC and net change in AWC from the TS change metrics. The TS attribution of disturbance matched the plot measurements 89% of the time regarding whether fire or harvest had occurred or not. The primary disagreement was due to plots that had been partially cut, mostly in vigorous stands where the net change in AWC over the measurement was positive in spite of cutting. The plot-measured AWC at time 2 was 86.0 ± 78.7 Mg C ha−1 (mean and standard deviation), and the change in AWC across all plots was 3.5 ± 33 Mg C ha−1 year−1. The best model for AWC based solely on TS and other mapped variables had an R2 = 0.52 (RMSE = 54.6 Mg C ha−1); applying this model at two time periods to estimate net change in AWC resulted in an R2 = 0.25 (RMSE = 28.3 Mg ha−1) and a mean error of −5.4 Mg ha−1. The best model for AWC at time 2 using plot measurements at time 1 and TS variables had an R2 = 0.95 (RSME = 17.0 Mg ha−1). The model for net change in AWC using the same data was identical except that, because the variable being estimated was smaller in magnitude, the R2 = 0.73. All models performed better at estimating net change in AWC on TS-disturbed plots than on TS-undisturbed plots. The TS discrimination of disturbance between fire and harvest was an important variable in the models because the magnitude of spectral change from fire was greater for a given change in AWC. Regional models without plot-level predictors produced erroneous predictions of net change in AWC for some of the forest types. Our study suggests that, in spite of the simplicity of applying a single carbon model to multiple image dates, the approach can produce inaccurate estimates of C flux. Although models built with plot-level predictors are necessarily constrained to making predictions at plot locations, they show promise for providing accurate updates or back-calculations of C flux assessments.

Climate related large scale variation in forest carbon turnover rate Evaluating global vegetation models using remote sensing products of biomass and NPP

Variations of Carbon Allocation and Turnover Time Across Tropical Forests

Evaluation of Climate-Related Carbon Turnover Processes in Global Vegetation Models for Boreal and Temperate Forests.

Understanding the uncertainty in global forest carbon turnover

Global Evaluation of Vegetation Carbon Residence Times as Simulated by ISI IMP2 Global Vegetation Models (GVMs) Using a Data Product based on Satellite and Eddy Covariance Flux …

Towards operational remote sensing of forest carbon balance across Northern Europe

Evaluating changes of biomass in global vegetation models: the role of turnover fluctuations and ENSO events

Transient and Lagged Effects of Vegetation Dynamics&#160;on the Global CO2 Growth Rate

Spatial heterogeneity of global forest aboveground carbon stocks and fluxes constrained by spaceborne lidar data and mechanistic modeling

Seasonal Variability of GPP and Phenology in Remote Sensed Observations and Land Surface Models

Net fluxes of broadband shortwave and photosynthetically active radiation complement NDVI and near infrared reflectance of vegetation to explain gross photosynthesis variability across ecosystems and climate

Detecting the Critical Periods That Underpin Interannual Fluctuations in the Carbon Balance of European Forests

Integrating TimeSync Disturbance Detection and Repeat Forest Inventory to Predict Carbon Flux

The Inter-Annual Variability of Africa's Ecosystem Productivity: a Multi-Model Analysis

Inter-annual Variability of Carbon and Water Fluxes in Amazonian Forest, Cerrado and Pasture Sites, As Simulated by Terrestrial Biosphere Models

Where does the carbon go? A model-data intercomparison of vegetation carbon allocation and turnover processes at two temperate forest free-air CO2 enrichment sites

Forest structure and vegetation dynamics as a driver of global carbon uptake

Carbon Stocks and Fluxes in the High Latitudes: Using Site-Level Data to Evaluate Earth System Models

Overlooked branch turnover creates a widespread bias in forest carbon accounting

Carbon Residence Time Dominates Uncertainty In Terrestrial Vegetation Responses To Future Climate And Atmospheric Co2

Comparison of multiple models for remote sensing of carbon exchange using MODIS data in conifer-dominated forests