Review of spacer grid to rod fretting in pressurized water reactor
Guillaume Ricciardi,Vincent Faucher,Lionel Rossi,Fabrice François,Bruno Collard,Philippe Bardet
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2024.112901
IF: 1.7
2024-01-19
Nuclear Engineering and Design
Abstract:In spite of the low fuel failure rate in currently operating water cooled nuclear power reactors, operations are increasingly demanding with higher burn-up, power increases, cycle lengths up to 24 months, challenging water chemistry, and the continuous goal of achieving a zero failure rate. All of these factors affect the available margins of the fuel assembly. Thus there is a continued high level of interest in fuel failures. It requires detailed knowledge of existing failure mechanisms, their root causes and remedies. Particularly, the fuel must remain robust against grid-to-rod-fretting, historically the most frequent cause of fuel failure in PWRs worldwide. Grid-to-rod fretting is a significant issue to address in nuclear power plants when considering optimized operating conditions and higher fuel burnups to increase economical performance. The sealing of the rod cladding must always be ensured to prevent unplanned reactor stops and wear resulting from frictional contact between fuel rods and their supporting devices is still the source of leakage worldwide despite significant improvements in the past two decades. The present paper is thus dedicated to the analysis of the fretting mechanism from a fluid–structure interaction point of view. It first introduces theoretical concepts enlightening the basics of turbulent fluid excitation and associated vibratory response of one single tube or a simplified bundle taking into account the mandatory time and space correlations seen in the excitation spectra. The different components of the practical industrial methods implemented to tackle the fretting issues are then described, starting with advanced insights into turbulent spectra in bundle configuration including detailed structures such as supporting grids. A discussion of global flow distribution on rod vibration is also included. Mechanical vibrations are next presented in details, especially in terms of non-linear response, including gaps and contacts in the vicinity of the supports, and time-domain loadings computed from the fluid turbulence spectra previously introduced. Finally, the methods to predict wear from well-chosen quantities extracted from structural dynamics are presented, taking into account the specific materials properties in contact and the lubrication provided by the flowing coolant in the reactor.
nuclear science & technology