Responsive to Whom? A Survey Experiment of the Influence of Superiors, Businesses, and Residents on China’s Subnational Officials

Tianguang Meng,Jennifer Pan

2015-01-01

Abstract:There growing interest in examining politics at the subnational level, not only because focusing downward increases the number of observations and analytical leverage, but because politics at the subnational level is meaningful in its own right. This is the case for China, where subnational units are a locus of decision-making for a wide range of policies. However, we know little about the relative influence of different stakeholders—superiors from upper-levels of government, societal actors—on subnational policymaking. Through direct questioning, a list experiment, and an endorsement experiment among over 2,000 subnational officials in China, we measure the compliance of prefectural-level officials to central demands as well as the responsiveness of these officials to local businesses and local residents. By minimizing social desirability bias through survey experiments, we find that the proportion of subnational officials who comply with the demands of upper-levels of government is similar to the proportion who are responsive to local businesses and local residents. Only half of prefecture-level officials consider the demands of higher-level government to be an important factor when making economic and social policy decisions, and slightly less than half of officials believe suggestions of local actors should be a primary consideration in these decisions.