Repairing Broken Continuity : Garden Heritage in the Historic Villages Xidi and Hongcun , China

Lei Gao,Jan Woudstra

2011-01-01

The Historic Environment Policy & Practice

Abstract:This paper investigates the role of local people in conservation by examining residential gardens and the concept of heritage in China. Current conservation guidelines (e.g. the Burra Charter, the China Principles) acknowledge local people as participants, however, their power is often curtailed and it is officials and professionals who are the real decision makers. The authors argue that local people ought to have a more significant role in some aspects of heritage conservation, but before doing so their association with heritage should be thoroughly understood. Two Chinese villages, Xidi and Hongcun, have interpreted conservation guidelines differently; one approach created museum-like conditions, where the emphasis lies on preserving the gardens as they were in 2000 (when the village was listed as a World Heritage Site). They can therefore only be appreciated at one level, namely as archaeological remnants without the whole range of sensory richness that would historically have been found in traditional gardens. In contrast, the other village paid less attention to historic fabric and created fortuitous circumstances, as a result of a greater need and freedom that saw the best conditions for restoration of its garden culture. Within the context of China’s rapid development this second approach may be of greater importance than the conservation of relics in a museum-like or archaeological sense.