Testing of gaseous fire suppressants in narrow channel apparatus

H. Wang,E. M. Kennedy,M. A. Delichatsios
2002-01-01
Abstract:In this paper, we develop a testing rig for ranking of halon replacements under conditions corresponding closely to fires of solid fuels. The rig is based on the narrow channel apparatus (3 mm in height, 110 mm in width and 375 mm in length), which allows the determination of the propagation velocity of creeping flames with and without fire suppressants. Strips of thick cardboard are placed at the bottom of a narrow channel, and a mixture of oxygen-enhanced air and an extinguishing agent is introduced into the channel in the direction opposite to propagating flames. The tests are taped and the propagation velocity is obtained simply by plotting the distance travelled by the flames as a function of time. Experiments were performed with dried and undried fuels, and at various gas flow rates to determine the range of operating conditions of the testing device. These experiments indicate great potential of the narrow-channel apparatus both as a testing and an experimental tool for evaluating halon replacements, under conditions, which are easily reproducible in a laboratory. The paper concludes with a presentation of the preliminary suppression results for mitigation of creeping flames with trifluoroiodomethane (CF3I). INTRODUCTION For most practical applications, it is desirable to test the effectiveness of gaseous fire suppression agents, in order to engineer effective fire-mitigation systems [1]. Usually, such tests are performed in the context of idealised gas-phase systems that are realised in laboratory-scale experiments by laminar pre-mixed flames to which a suppressant is added, with one measuring the laminar burning velocity, or flammability limits [1-6]. Laminar diffusion flames, either in counter-current (opposed flow) or co-current (cup burner) geometries provide other experimental configurations to study gas-phase extinguishment. Arguably, the latter (cup-burner) flames mirror more closely real fires, in terms of the fuel used, type of flames and strain rate at extinction. Most fires, however, involve solid fuels, necessitating the development of a testing device capable of ranking the effectiveness of gaseous fire suppressants on fires of solid fuels under controlled conditions. Flame spread is one of the most important parameters that characterise burning of solid fuels [7]. The flame spread itself varies with the type of solid fuel, its thickness, moisture content, grain orientation, heat flux received by the sample, as well as the composition and velocity of the incoming gases [7-9]. A narrow channel apparatus [10-12] provides a convenient setting to study flame spread over solid fuels and to test the effect of fire suppressants on flame propagation. The apparatus was first introduced in the former Soviet Union [10] to determine the behaviour of flames propagating under microgravity-like conditions. It consists of two-dimensional HelleShaw cell, a few millimetres in thickness, with a flat specimen of a solid fuel attached to the bottom plate. The gas diffuser, introducing O2/N2 mixture into the channel, and the point of ignition are separated by the length of the channel to induce creeping (counter-current) flames. Flames are easily established and move forward on the fuel surface at a steady rate, in the direction opposite to the gas flow. The narrow-channel apparatus possesses several attractive features that simplify the fluid mechanics, and to some extent the heat transfer processes, permitting the practitioner to use the device as a testing apparatus and allowing the researcher to concentrate on studying the kinetics of interaction of fire suppressants with well-defined laminar diffusion flames of solid fuels. The flow in the narrow channel is laminar and two-dimensional, except at very high gas velocities when the side boundary conditions may become important. Once the apparatus is oriented horizontally, the effect of gravity, manifesting itself as the buoyancy force, becomes negligible due to the small channel height. With respect to heat transfer, the heat conduction in the solid ahead of the flame front is the dominant heat transfer mechanism in the flame spread [7-9]. Thus, only for thermally-thick materials the conduction become independent of the fuel thickness. The gaseous products transported by the gas stream can be easily collected downstream in the HelleShaw geometry for toxicity and combustion by-product testing. This work aims at exploring the operation and results from the narrow channel apparatus to determine whether or not the apparatus can be used as a testing method to evaluate gaseous fire suppressants on fires of solid fuels. A narrow channel apparatus was constructed based on the information reported in the literature, with tests performed at various flow rates of O2/N2 mixture. This allowed to determine a range of conditions suitable for operating the device for testing applications. Preliminary suppression experiments were carried out with various concentration of
What problem does this paper attempt to address?