Evaluation for the performance of the Guangdong-Hongkong-Macau Lightning Location System
Yijun Zhang,Weitao Lu,Yang Zhang,Dong Zheng
2014-01-01
Abstract:In this paper, the performance characteristics of the Guangdong-Hongkong-Macau Lightning Location System (GHMLLS) was evaluated based on observations of lightning flashes triggered at the Guangzhou Field Experiment Site for Lightning Research and Testing during 2007-2013, and natural lightning flashes to tall structures in Guangzhou during 20092012. Both experiment sites are located in the center area of the GHMLLS after the upgrade in 2012, but slightly outside of that before 2012. Considering the significant increasing of the number of sensors in 2012, the evaluations were performed according to two different periods of 2007-2011 and 2012-2013 respectively, and the performance characteristics during the two periods were compared. The results show that the flash detection efficiency, stroke detection efficiency, the arithmetic mean value and median value for location error were estimated to be about 64%, 22%, 2 330 m and 1 370 m for triggered lightning during 20072011, while the corresponding values were about 86%, 91%, 590 m and 400 m during 2012-2013. The flash detection efficiency, stroke detection efficiency, the arithmetic mean value and median value for location error were estimated to be about 82%, 58%, 2 820 m and 930 m for natural lightning during 2009-2011, while the corresponding values were about 97%, 90%, 950 m and 470 m during 2012. Directly measurement of peak current of return strokes of triggered lightning was not obtained in 2007 due to various reasons. During 2008 to 2011, for 14 return stroke processes of artificially triggered lightning, both the directly measurement of peak currents and the corresponding GHMLLS records were obtained. 13 out of the 14 peak currents were underestimated by GHMLLS and only one was overestimated, and the absolute percentage errors of peak current estimation were within 16.2% to 96.2%, with arithmetic mean value and median value of about 34% and 26%. On the other hand, during 2012-2013, all the 32 peak currents , both the directly measurement of peak currents and the corresponding GHMLLS records were obtained, were overestimated by GHMLLS, and the absolute percentage errors of peak current estimation ranged from 31% to 421%, with arithmetic mean value and median value of about 217% and 220%. When the number of sensors was significantly increased in 2012, the detection efficiency and location precision of GHMLLS were found to be obviously improved, but the peak currents of return strokes were abnormally overestimated. Keywords—Lightning Location System; Performance; Triggered Lightning; Natural Lightning