Middle Eastern Studies

Chaoqun Lian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s42533-021-00086-8

2024-01-01

China International Strategy Review

Abstract:This volume is the first monograph in English that discusses the militaries of Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) states. The book is devoted to addressing the following puzzle: “why are the armies of Arabia so ineffective despite the enormous resources expended upon them” (300–301)? Barany identifies a combination of political-structural and sociocultural variables that together bring about the lackluster performance of GCC armies. With regard to political-structural variables, he argues that what he understands as the “absolute monarchy” of these states plays a fundamental role by making the main function of these armies “not the defense of the nation but, ultimately, the protection of the monarchical regime from its domestic challengers” (9). In GCC states, it is often the case that individual ruling elites and their circles built through nepotism and tribalism, rather than representative institutions based on meritocracy, determine the path of military development. In addition, the monarchies in these states create rival forces to prevent potential coups to preserve their rule. A further concomitant of this monarchy-oriented military building is the de facto reliance of these states on American and/or British forces as “the real defenders or true primary security providers” (10). Even arms procurement from America and its allies is mainly aimed at guaranteeing this provision of security. As for sociocultural variables, Barany highlights the “societal preference for conformity and obedience” that hinders “critical thinking and independent initiative” (12), “the absence of direct accountability and criticism” (13) partly due to a culture of honor that equates criticism with humiliation, religious fatalism that weakens personal agency, and the enjoyment of state-provided economic benefits that demotivates military aspiration. The book consists of six thematic chapters. Chapter 1 examines “key sociocultural foundations and formative moments” (15) of GCC armies, including: tribes and tribalism; the history of the Wahhabi militia, Ikhwan; Britain’s historical involvement in Arabia; the creation of the UAE and its military force; the Iraqi