Abstract:The goal of this study is to expand our understanding of the relationships between selected tasks, cognitive abilities and search result interfaces. The underlying objective is to understand how to select search results presentation for tasks and user contexts. Twenty three participants conducted four search tasks of two types and used two interfaces (List and Overview) to refine and examine search results. Clickthrough data were recorded. This controlled study employed a mixed model design with two within-subject factors (task and interface) and two between-subject factors (two cognitive abilities: memory span and verbal closure). Quantitative analyses were carried out by means of the statistical package SPSS. Specifically, multivariate analysis of variance with repeated measures and non-parametric tests were performed on the collected data. The overview of search results appeared to have benefited searchers in several ways. It made them faster; it facilitated formulation of more effective queries and helped to assess search results. Searchers with higher cognitive abilities were faster in the Overview interface and in less demanding situations (on simple tasks), while at the same time they issued about the same number of queries as lower-ability searchers. In more demanding situations (on complex tasks and in the List interface), the higher ability searchers expended more search effort, although they were not significantly slower than the lower ability people in these situations. The higher search effort, however, did not result in a measurable improvement of task outcomes for high-ability searchers. These findings have implications for the design of search interfaces. They suggest benefits of providing result overviews. They also suggest the importance of considering cognitive abilities in the design of search results' presentation and interaction.

Exploring the Effect of Task Difficulty and Domain Knowledge on Dwell times

Task Difficulty and Domain Knowledge Effects on Information Search Behaviors

The Exploration of Objective Task Difficulty and Domain Knowledge Effects on Users' Query Formulation

Exploring and predicting search task difficulty.

Predicting Search Task Difficulty at Different Search Stages.

The Effect of Task Type and Topic Familiarity on Information Search Behaviors

Understanding searchers' perception of task difficulty: Relationships with task type

Using dwell time as an implicit measure of usefulness in different task types

Can Search Systems Detect Users' Task Difficulty?: Some Behavioral Signals

Exploration of the Behavioral Model of User-Web Interaction

Predicting task difficulty for different task types

How Does Domain Expertise Affect User's Search Interaction and Outcome in Exploratory Search?

A Comparative Study of the Relationship between the Subjective Difficulty, Objective Difficulty of Search Tasks and Search Behaviors

The Role of the Task Topic in Web Search of Different Task Types

Searching, browsing, and clicking in a search session: changes in user behavior by task and over time

Preliminary Exploration of the Effect of Time Constraint on Search Interactions on Webpages

What a Difference a Tag Cloud Makes: Effects of Tasks and Cognitive Abilities on Search Results Interface Use

Examining the effects of task topic familiarity on searchers' behaviors in different task types

The Impact of Technical Domain Expertise on Search Behavior and Task Outcome

Still Haven't Found What You're Looking For -- Detecting the Intent of Web Search Missions from User Interaction Features

Search behaviors in different task types.