Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this paper is to estimate the effectiveness of the credit evaluation system using the borrowing data from China’s leading P2P lending platform, Renrendai.com. Design/methodology/approach The current credit valuation systems are classified into the forward-looking mechanism, which judges the borrowers’ credit levels based on their uploaded information, and the backward-looking mechanism, which judges the borrowers’ credit levels based on their historical repayment performance. Probit models and Tobit models are used to examine the effectiveness of credit evaluation mechanisms. Findings The results show that only the “hard” information reflecting borrowers’ credit ability can explain the default risk on the platform under the forward-looking credit evaluation mechanism. The backward-looking credit evaluation mechanism (BCEM) based on the repeated borrowings produces both promise-enhancing and “fishing” incentives and thus fails to explain the default risk, and weakens the effectiveness of forward-looking credit indicators in explaining the default risk because it encourages borrowers to invest in forging forward-looking credit indicators. Additional information such as the interest rate and the repayment periods reveals borrowers’ credit and thus can also be used as a predictor of borrowers’ default risk. Practical implications The findings suggest that current ex ante screening based on the information collected from the borrowers or repeated borrowings is inadequate to control the default risk in P2P lending markets and thus needs be improved. Ex post monitoring and sharing on defaulter’s information should be strengthened to increase the default cost and thus to deter potential bad borrowers. Originality/value To the authors’ knowledge, this is the first paper classifying the credit evaluation system in online P2P lending market into the forward-looking type and the backward-looking type, which is important since they provide different incentives to borrowers. The paper also investigates and provides evidence on the promise-enhancing and “fishing” incentives of BCEMs.

Carrot or Stick? Evidence from a Pair of Randomized Field Experiments Testing Lender Information Sharing Hypotheses

What if Borrowers Were Informed about Credit Reporting? Two Natural Field Experiments

Drivers and consequences of borrowers' voluntary privacy information disclosure—Evidence from a Chinese online consumer financing platform

Forward Looking Versus Backward Looking: An Empirical Study on the Effectiveness of Credit Evaluation System in China's Online P2P Lending Market

Borrower's Self-Disclosure of Social Media Information in P2P Lending

Predicting and Deterring Default with Social Media Information in Peer-to-Peer Lending.

Forward Looking Vs Backward Looking

Prosocial Compliance in P2P Lending: A Natural Field Experiment

Information Sharing and Rationing in Credit Markets

The Influence of Borrowers' Language Features on P2P Lending

Friends, Colleagues or Neighbors? Influential Peers in Microloan Defaults

The role of social and psychological related soft information in credit analysis: Evidence from a Fintech Company

Disparity and Discrimination in Consumer Credit Markets: Evidence from Online Peer-to-peer Lending

Are Demographic Variable the Effective Indicator to Predict Credit Debt Behavior

Assessment of Borrowers' Delinquency and Default Behaviors in Online P2P Lending: A Two-stage Model.

How Do Machine Learning and Non-Traditional Data Affect Credit Scoring? New Evidence from a Chinese Fintech Firm

Policy Uncertainty and Household Credit Access: Evidence from Peer-to-Peer Crowdfunding

Understanding Default Behavior in Peer-to-Peer Lending

The Effects of Auction‐based Pricing Mechanisms and Social Characteristics on Microloan Performance

Borrower Learning Effects: Do Prior Experiences Promote Continuous Successes in Peer-to-Peer Lending?

The predicting power of soft information on defaults in the Chinese P2P lending market