Identity Discrimination: A Study on Efficiency of Internet Financial Innovation——Based on P2P Network Lending
Lei ZHUANG,Qin ZHOU
DOI: https://doi.org/10.19616/j.cnki.bmj.2015.04.016
2015-01-01
Abstract:Identity discrimination in the financial markets is a common phenomenon,which is expressed as a variety of financial barriers.Especially it is more obvious in the Chinese financial market because of relatively low degree of openness in the financial sector.It is easier to obtain loans for enterprises which have a political background than those private enterprises.In the same way,it is easier to get personal loans from the bank or lower interest rate for the officials than others.However,Internet financial model innovation in China can make financial markets more efficient.It is an interesting topic that the paper tests the efficiency of Internet financial from the degree of identity discrimination on the P2 P networks lending.Information asymmetry is the main reason for discrimination in financial markets.In case of lack of information,a variety of labels(including the identity) will play a role in signal transduction.Capital occupants set financial threshold according to the label,which is not conducive to free flow of capital and reduces the financial efficiency ultimately.The degree of identity discrimination may reflect social and economic development.The more developed the economy and society,the less obvious identity discrimination is in the financing process.Internet finance improves the efficiency of information processing by using advanced information technology,and reduces the degree of information asymmetry,which can remit discrimination in the financial markets.So,this paper tests the efficiency of Internet financial innovation by an empirical study of the degree of status discrimination on the P2 P network lending.Information(mainly credit information) is the basis of capital allocation in the financial market Investors generally choose and determine whether to invest a project according to the information signal in the financial markets(including price,credit rating,personal information,etc.).The investors will generally invest when they observe the quality of information disclosure on an item than they expect it.Then the paper constructs a general model which the quality of information disclosure affect the success of loans.Combined with the actual situation of Internet financial development in China,the paper proposes two assumptions on the P2 P network lending:(1) there is identity discrimination on the whole in the network lending markets;(2) the trend of identity discrimination eases with the development of information disclosure.Considering specific operability of two assumptions on the network lending,the paper proposes six experimental hypotheses.According to the analysis of theory model,assumptions and statistical analysis of the transaction data in the ppdai.com,the paper researches the discrimination level of identity discrimination from three angles such as winning probability,bid popularity,interest rates of borrowing orders.The empirical results showed that it exits significantly identity discrimination as a low quality of information disclosure in the overall network lending.Then it does not exist significantly identity discrimination after further testing market segments of higher information quality.According to the result of robustness test by the amount of loan orders,the paper further proofs that identity discrimination is reducing with a higher quality of information disclosure in the market segments.Borrowers can be refined in the network lending market by the improvement of information disclosure system,and investors can invest according to detailed information.Thus it alleviates identity discrimination in the financial markets.Therefore,with the in-depth development of Internet Finance in China,it will improve information symmetry,ease identity discrimination,and improve the efficiency of financial markets.From a policy perspective,suggestions should be considered the following aspects:(1) encouraging Internet financial innovation and taking standardized management measures,(2) improving the information disclosure system of lending network and formulating a series of safe and effective disclosure standards,(3) forming a good credit system of network lending and integrating credit system of the whole society.