Syntax-discourse interface in English speakers’ L2 acquisition of Chinese wh-topicalization

Boping Yuan,Esuna Dugarova
2011-01-01
Abstract:Chinese has been widely considered a wh-in-situ language, in which the wh-word remains in situ in wh-questions, as in (1a). However, the wh-word can be topicalized, moving from the base-generated position to the sentence initial position, as in (1b).(1) a. Ni chi le shenme cai? You eat PFV what dish “What dish (es) did you eat? b.[Shenme cai] i ni meiyou chi ti? What dish you didn’t eat “What dish (es) did you not eat?” The wh-topicalization is determined at the syntax-discourse interface, and only D (iscourse)-linked wh-words can undergo topicalization and non-D-linked wh-words cannot (see Li 1996, Pan 2006, Tang 1988, Wu 1999, and Xu and Langedoen 1985). For the wh-topicalization to be felicitous in Chinese, the interlocutors in the discourse must “have a set of things in the presupposition background”, whereas in wh-in-situ questions,“no particular set of things… is presupposed”(Wu 1999, p. 83). To answer a question like (1a), one is not constrained by a particular set of dishes from which one has to choose from, and in fact, anything that can be called a cai (= dish) can be used to answer the question in (1a). To answer the question like (1b), however, one is restricted to a set of dishes that have already been established in the previous discourse. This makes it possible for the wh-phrase shenme cai (= what dish) to be topicalized in (1b).
What problem does this paper attempt to address?