Abstract:This paper presents experimental results showing that four-year-old Mandarin- speaking children draw free choice inferences from disjunctive statements, though they are not able to compute inferences of exclusivity for disjunctive statements or other scalar implicatures. The findings connect to those of Chemla & Bott (under review) who report differences in how adults process free choice inferences versus scalar implicatures and, prima facie, the findings pose a challenge to treatments that attempt to unify inferences of both kinds. Instead, the findings appear to favour accounts that invoke different analyses for each kind of inference, such as Zimmerman 2000a, Geurts 2005, and Barker 2010. The results, however, also support the recent approach in the experimental literature which attributes children’s failures to compute scalar implicatures to a difficulty with alternatives: children may lack the lexical knowledge of alternatives, or these implicatures impose such a high processing cost that children are unable to handle the alternatives necessary to compute them (Gualmini, Crain, Meroni, Chierchia & Guasti 2001 Chierchia, Crain, Guasti & Thornton 2001 Reinhart 2006; Barner, Brooks & Bale 2011; Singh, Wexler, Astle, Kamawar & Fox 2012). If accessing alternatives is the source of children’s difficulty, then they would be expected to perform better if the requisite alternatives are made explicit, as sub-strings of the asserted sentences. This is exactly what we found. Children were able to compute free choice inferences based on alternatives that were made explicit in the assertion, but children were unable to compute ‘regular’ scalar implicatures arising from alternatives lacking this property. We discuss the implications of these findings for the debate about the relationship between free choice inferences and scalar implicatures and children’s knowledge of alternatives.

Children’s Knowledge of the Quantifier Dou in Mandarin Chinese

Wh-Questions, Universal Statements and Free Choice Inferences in Child Mandarin.

Children's Knowledge of Wh-Quantification in Mandarin Chinese

The Interpretation of Disjunction in the Scope of Dou in Child Mandarin.

The Quantificational Domain of dou: An Experimental Study

Chinese Dou Quantification

The Relations Between Cardinal Number Knowledge and Quantifier Comprehension

Scope Assignment in Child Language: Evidence from the Acquisition of Chinese

Children’s knowledge of double negative structures in Mandarin Chinese

Children’s knowledge of double negative structuresin Mandarin Chinese

Children’s Knowledge of Ellipsis Constructions in Mandarin Chinese

Chapter 11. The meaning of question words in statements in child Mandarin

Children’s Interpretation of Ambiguous Wh-Adjuncts in Mandarin Chinese

The Development of Quantity Implicatures in Mandarin-Speaking Children

Donkey Pronouns in Child Mandarin: Insights into the ∃/∀ Dichotomy

Preschool Mandarin-speaking Children’s Comprehension of Associative Anaphora

Differences in Scope Assignments for Child and Adult Speakers of Mandarin

Interface Conditions in Child Language: A View from Mandarin Chinese

How Possessive Relations Are Mapped Onto Child Language: A View from Mandarin Chinese.

Children's Knowledge of Free Choice Inferences

Syntactic Cues to the Noun and Verb Distinction in Mandarin Child-Directed Speech