Top-Down or Multi-Party Collaboration: A Comparative Study on Spatial Governance of Built-up Areas in the Developed Regions of China

GUO Xu,TIAN Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.16361/j.upf.201801008

2018-01-01

Abstract:Under the background of new urbanization,land utilization in developed regions is switching from increment planning to reserve planning.As spatial governance has been incorporated into the national strategy,the significance in the governance of land reserves for construction has become increasingly obvious.Different from the conventional planning for increments,the core of governance of land reserves for construction is the transaction of property rights on land and the distribution of land incomes.There are two typical management modes in the developed regions in China:one is the top-down mode,i.e.,"project governance" led by regional governments;and the other is the multi-party collaborative mode,i.e.,redevelopment by joint efforts of the original land owners,regional governments and other parties involved in the market.In the research,Shanghai and Guangzhou are taken as examples to compare the different practice in terms of institutional arrangement,planning and management,realization and distribution of land incomes,and public involvement.It is found that the key to good governance of land reserves for construction is respect of the benefits of the original land owners,other market players as well as public interest to ensure social justice.