Rural Experience and Stock Market Participation
Jinglin JIANG,Zhengwei WANG,Li LIAO
2018-01-01
Abstract:Summary:Limited stock market participation is a key issue in household finances.Although standard theory predicts universal participation, empirical investigations find that many households do not participate in the stock market and so do not earn equity premiums.The literature uses fixed participation costs, nonstandard preferences, beliefs and a lack of trust to explain this issue.However, these attributes can only explain a part of the wide dispersion in participation rates.Because the stock market is an important investment tool for households to increase their wealth, promoting stock market participation benefits China's real economy.Hence, limited stock market participation is an important topic from both academic and practical perspectives.This study examines an important but unappreciated determinant of stock market participation:early-life experiences.A large literature in finance shows that personal life experiences influence people's risk-taking behavior both in the laboratory and in the field.Yet, the long-run effect of early-life experiences on stock market participation behavior has been ignored to date.In this paper, we focus on the impact of early-life experiences on stock market participation.China, with its large rural-urban disparity, provides an ideal research setting for two reasons.First, being exposed to a rural environment for a long time at a young age is a randomly assigned characteristic due to the strict migration restrictions that existed for several decades.Whether one is exposed to rural areas is determined by where one is born, which cannot be altered.Second, unlike in most developed countries, there are huge socioeconomic differences in both the immediate setting and the social systems of rural and urban areas.In this dual system, living in rural areas implies a totally different ecology for children compared with those living in urban areas.This salient disparity makes it a credible identification of childhood exposure.Third, concerns over selection bias can be addressed in this setting because rural residents are much less educated than urban residents with rural experiences during childhood.This paper examines whether childhood rural experiences affect the stock market participation of urban residents using individual-level data in China.Using CFPS data, we identify rural experiences by Hukou Registration Type in childhood.In our empirical test, we find that rural experiences deter stock market participation.The economic magnitude of the effect is quite large;individuals with rural experience are 5.4％less likely to participate in the stock market, which is equivalent to a 44％decrease in the unconditional probability of participation (12.2％).The finding holds true even after we control for personal differences in trust, social interactions, risk attitudes, financial literacy, early-life socioeconomic status and a large set of household demographic and economic characteristics.Providing further evidence, the relation between rural experiences and stock market participation does not weaken with wealth.This implies that early-life experiences explain why even the rich stay away from the stock market even though they can afford the fixed participation cost.Building on these findings, we further investigate what can mitigate the adverse effect of rural experiences on stock market participation.Inspired by the literature on personality traits, we hypothesize that the influence of openness affects the relation between rural experiences and stock market participation.We find that a higher level of openness significantly mitigates the rural experience effect.In fact, we find that rural childhood exposure does not have an impact on stock market participation among people with high levels of openness.These findings are consistent with the predictions of psychology.Our study's main contribution is to consider early-life experiences as underlying determinants of stock market participation.To the best of our knowledge, the relation between early-life experiences and stock market participation has not been well addressed by the literature, especially in China's setting.We show that people's decisions to hold stocks are related to their rural experiences.Moreover, our findings provide new evidence for the long-run effect of childhood experiences on individual economic decisions.