Abstract:nigel.hawkes1@btinternet.com Do published outcomes tell us what’s really going on inside a hospital? Nigel Hawkes reports on how standardised mortality ratios at Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust came to conceal the hospital’s failings The new NHS in England aims to empower the patient and shame failing hospitals by measuring and publishing outcomes. Open data will make health providers honest and patients better able to choose between them. How simple is that? Rather too simple, to judge by evidence presented to the public inquiry into Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust, which has shown that the old NHS had ingenious ways of burnishing its outcomes and concealing its failings. Even death, the most unambiguous outcome of all, lost its sting when changes in coding practice resulted in many deaths being excluded from the calculation of hospital mortality ratios. Whether this amounted to actual dishonesty may never be determined. In his final submission Tom Kark, counsel to the inquiry, suggested that it may not be necessary for Robert Francis, the inquiry’s chair, to make any finding of fact over claims that Mid-Staffs and two other West Midlands trusts engaged in a plan to lower their apparent mortality ratios by changing the way patients were coded.1 Nor did Kark reach any firm conclusion over the suggestion that West Midlands Strategic Health Authority (SHA) sought to muddy the waters by commissioning a critical report into mortality measures, published in the BMJ, from academics known to disbelieve in the method. Both these charges were made in evidence to the inquiry by Professor Brian Jarman, the father of the hospital standardised mortality ratio (HSMR, see box), which has been used for the past decade by the health analytics company Dr Foster to compare hospital performance. By his reckoning, West Midlands tried to undermine the mortality data …

England’s Health Department Avoids Breaching Budget on “Technicality”

Health department lacks grip on spending and clinical negligence payouts, MPs warn

NHS in England Balances Books, but Local Deficits Mean Worse Care in Some Areas, Says Report

Hospitals’ Reported £1bn Deficit Masks True Scale of Financial Woes, Say Analysts

NHS overspend reaches £2.3bn

Hospitals in England See Deficits Grow As Wage Bills Rise and Earning Capacity Falls.

Between a Fifth and a Third of Hospitals Record Inaccurate Cost Data

England's NHS Faces a Funding Crisis, Report Says.

What did the budget do for the NHS's financial health?

Statistics Chief Asks for Clarity on Source of "new" NHS Money

Hospitals Pay Penalties of 1.2bn for "too Many" Admissions and "too Early" Discharges

English Nhs Could Be 54bn Pound In Red By 2021 If Budget Or Output Doesn'T Increase

Helen Salisbury: A budget to end GPs' trust and goodwill

Budget 2024: Extra {pound}22.6bn for NHS isn't enough to rebuild NHS, say health leaders

Did the Government Ignore Criticisms of the NHSin the Run Up to the Mid Staffs Scandal?

The Better Care Fund: a Disaster in Waiting?

How the Message from Mortality Figures Was Missed at Mid Staffs

Longer Waits in Emergency Departments Are Inevitable As Services Reach Capacity, Report Finds

NHS needs another £65bn by 2030-31, think tank says.

Losing NHS doctors early is costing {pound}2.4bn a year, BMA estimates

BMA defends consultants in row about overtime pay after BBC report