Modeling the impact of product quality on dynamic pricing and advertising policies

Régis Chenavaz,Gustav Feichtinger,Richard F. Hartl,Peter M. Kort

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2020.01.035

IF: 6.4

2020-01-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:•Study the pricing–advertising–quality relationship.•Provide an optimal control application.•Generalize the condition of Dorfman–Steiner (1954).

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Dynamic Pricing, Reference Price, and Price-Quality Relationship

Ramona Anton,Regis Y. Chenavaz,Corina Paraschiv

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jedc.2022.104586

2023-01-01

Abstract:The price-quality relationship receives attention from both practitioners and scholars. Yet, the reference price effect, a central aspect in modeling consumer behavior, is absent from the debate. This article addresses the role of the reference price dynamics in understanding the price-quality relationship. We develop an optimal control model of the dynamic behavior of a firm setting price and quality investment over time, accounting for a reference price effect based on prior selling prices. We contribute to the literature on the price-quality relationship by highlighting the conditions under which better quality may drive a lower price when consumers are prone to a reference price. Analytical results show that a counterintuitive negative price-quality relationship may appear even with a linear demand function. Numerical results emphasize the importance of the initial market conditions in the negative price-quality relationship.
An analytical model of the relationship between product quality and advertising.

Régis Chenavaz,Sajjad M. Jasimuddin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2017.05.016

IF: 6.4

2017-01-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:•Optimal control model with advertising and product quality.•Explanation of both positive and negative advertising-quality relationships.•Proof of the conjecture of Tellis and Fornell (1988) as special case.•We provide testable empirical implications.
On dynamic policies for quality, price and advertising

Chinho Lin,Jong-Mau Yeh,Jieh-Rern Ding,Yichen Lin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02522667.1999.10699428

1999-09-01

Journal of Information and Optimization Sciences

Abstract:This study presents a novel algorithm to derive the long term policies of quality level, price, and advertisement for a new product. The diffusion model of marketing is also combined with the experience curve phenomenon of cost to formulate a profit function capable of discounting future profit streams. To maximize the profits, the optimal conditions of the profit function are initially derived by the optimal control theory and then, the genetic algorithm is implemented to search for the approximation solutions of quality level, price, and advertising expenditure at each period on the planning horizon (life cycle). In addition, an illustrative example is presented to describe the results obtained herein. Those results are used to perform the sensitivity analysis for the major parameters to specify their effects on profits. Results in this study allow us to achieve the following: (a) simultaneously solve the quality, price, and advertising policy so that explicit solutions can be obtained for firms, (b) propose a more appropriate dynamic model to demonstrate the evolutionary forces in a commercial environment, and (c) enhance the long term profit performance via the polices proposed herein, i.e., the approximation of the best solution.
Dynamic Quality Policies with Reference Quality Effects

Regis Chenavaz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00036846.2016.1254345

IF: 1.916

2016-01-01

Applied Economics

Abstract:ABSTRACT Dynamic pricing policies with reference-price demand have been intensely analysed. Less studied are dynamic quality policies with reference-quality demand. This article studies the dynamic quality policy of a firm whose consumers use a reference point in their decision-making, in line with the principles of behavioural economics. More specifically, I consider reference quality formation in an optimal control setting. By solving on the basis of Pontryagin’s maximum principle, I obtain analytical solutions to the optimal quality policy. The managerial implications of quality reference for dynamic quality policy are discussed.
Dynamic optimal control policy in advertising price and quality

Chinho Lin,Shin-Yu Shen,Yih-Jyh Yeh,Jieh-Rern Ding

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00207720118596

IF: 2.648

2001-01-01

International Journal of Systems Science

Abstract:This study presents an algorithm for deriving the long-term polices of quality level, price and advertisement for a product. The diffusion models and cost functions are combined to formulate profit functions capable of determining future profit trends. The algorithm first implements the optimal control theory to derive the optimal conditions of the profit function. Then the genetic algorithm is employed to search for the approximate solutions of quality level, price and advertising expenditure at each period on the planning horizon (life cycle). Examples of different scenarios of the model parameters are presented to describe the results obtained herein. Sensitivity analysis for the major parameters is performed to specify their effects on profits. Results in this study allow us, firstly, to obtain explicit solutions simultaneously with respect to quality, price and advertising policies, secondly, to propose an appropriate algorithm for solving the different scenarios of the dynamic profit function, which consists of the diffusion function and cost function, and thirdly, to enhance the long-term profit performance via the polices proposed herein, that is the approximation of the best solution.

automation & control systems,computer science, theory & methods,operations research & management science
Dynamic pricing , product innovation , and quality-based cost

Régis Chenavaz

2013-01-01

Abstract:Manufacturing and high-tech firms simultaneously conduct dynamic pricing and product innovation policies. We model these policies in an optimal control framework. On the supply-side, the firm conducts the pricing and the product innovation policies. The cost of production is related to product quality. On the demand-side, the consumer has interest in price and quality. We analyse the determinants of dynamic pricing and the effect of quality on price. We show that the dynamic pricing is only linked to the characteristics of the demand. Under a general demand function, price dynamics is ambiguous; price may decrease even if quality and cost increase. Under an additive separable demand function, price dynamics follows quality dynamics; the pricing curve emulates the quality curve. Under a multiplicative separable demand function, price dynamics follows cost dynamics; the pricing curve emulates the cost curve.
A Joint Dynamic Pricing and Multi-Channel Advertising Model with Stochastic Demand

Rainer Schlosser,Régis Chenavaz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3842061

2021-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:To attract potential customers and to effectively sell their inventories over time, retailers often invest in different advertising channels and apply dynamic pricing strategies. However, to compose a beneficial marketing mix in dynamic settings is challenging. The high problem complexity is further increased if one seeks to account for stochastic and inventory-dependent demand, which is essential for various practical applications. In this paper, we examine such stochastic dynamic pricing and advertising models under a finite as well as an infinite time horizon. For a fairly general demand formulation with asymmetric advertising channels, we generalize the classical condition of Dorfman-Steiner to dynamic multi-channel advertising. Further, we show how to transform the multi-dimensional control problem into a two-dimensional one, simplifying the analytical complexity. Finally, for well-established cases with isoelastic and exponential demand, we present optimal closed-form solutions, which allow for detailed sensitivity analyses. Using numerical examples, we illustrate and analyze optimally controlled sales processes and infer managerial insights. Our explicit results provide general qualitative and quantitative insights in the complex interplay of marketing mix controls over time.
Dynamic Pricing and Advertising with Demand Learning

Shipra Agrawal,Yiding Feng,Wei Tang

2024-12-11

Abstract:We consider a novel pricing and advertising framework, where a seller not only sets product price but also designs flexible 'advertising schemes' to influence customers' valuation of the product. We impose no structural restriction on the seller's feasible advertising strategies and allow her to advertise the product by disclosing or concealing any information. Following the literature in information design, this fully flexible advertising can be modeled as the seller being able to choose any information policy that signals the product quality/characteristic to the customers. Customers observe the advertising signal and infer a Bayesian belief over the products. We aim to investigate two questions in this work: (1) What is the value of advertising? To what extent can advertising enhance a seller's revenue? (2) Without any apriori knowledge of the customers' demand function, how can a seller adaptively learn and optimize both pricing and advertising strategies using past purchase responses? To study the first question, we introduce and study the value of advertising - a revenue gap between using advertising vs not advertising, and we provide a crisp tight characterization for this notion for a broad family of problems. For the second question, we study the seller's dynamic pricing and advertising problem with demand uncertainty. Our main result for this question is a computationally efficient online algorithm that achieves an optimal $O(T^{2/3}(m\log T)^{1/3})$ regret rate when the valuation function is linear in the product quality. Here $m$ is the cardinality of the discrete product quality domain and $T$ is the time horizon. This result requires some mild regularity assumptions on the valuation function, but no Lipschitz or smoothness assumption on the customers' demand function. We also obtain several improved results for the widely considered special case of additive valuations.

Computer Science and Game Theory,Machine Learning
A dynamic advertising model with reference price effect

Qiao Zhang,Jianxiong Zhang,Wansheng Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/ro/2014063

2015-03-27

Abstract:This paper develops an advertising model in which goodwill affected by advertising effort has a positive effect on reference price and market demand. In a finite planning horizon, the optimal advertising strategy is provided by solving the optimization problem on the basis of Pontryagin’s maximum principle, then the optimal sales price is obtained through one time pricing strategy. Furthermore, we extend this problem to an infinite planning horizon and present the corresponding optimal strategies. In addition, the relationships between system parameters and optimal solutions are analyzed. Numerical examples are employed to illustrate the effectiveness of the theoretical results, and to assess the sensitivity analysis of system parameters on the optimal strategies.
Quality Improvement and Pricing with Reference Quality Effect

Musen Xue,Jianxiong Zhang,Wansheng Tang,Rui Dai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11518-017-5331-y

2017-01-01

Abstract:This article studies a problem of joint pricing and dynamic product quality investment with consumers’ reference quality effect under the existence of quality inflation. Optimal control models are constructed to maximize the total profit with a limited quality investment capacity, where the demand is sensitive to historical product quality level. The optimal quality investment strategies for finite and infinite planning horizon are given respectively by solving these optimal control models on the basis of Pontryagin’s maximum principle, which enables the exact trajectory of the optimal quality investment with the reference quality effect over time to be depicted. In addition, an effective algorithm is designed to generate the optimal joint pricing and dynamic quality investment policy for the system. The main difference between the strategy of finite planning horizon and that of infinite planning horizon is that the latter is a constant. Our study indicates that it is never optimal for firm to increase quality investment all the way throughout the planning horizon. The level of quality investment is higher when taking into account the impact of reference quality. Moreover, numerical example is given to illustrate the validness of the theoretical results. Also, sensitivity analysis is carried out to show how system parameters affect the optimal policies, and some managerial suggestions are presented.
Dynamic pricing and product/process r&d with reference quality effect in a monopoly

Lijia Ge,Shoude Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3934/jimo.2022248

2023-01-01

Journal of Industrial and Management Optimization

Abstract:In this article, we construct a dynamic optimal control model where the price and R&D portfolio are simultaneously determined by a monopolist with the consumers' reference effect about product quality. We extend the conventional model by describing the product and process R&D with non-linear dynamic equations and considering the signal effect of price on the change rate of reference quality. Our analysis mainly suggests that: (i) the non-linear system admits at most two steady-state saddle-point equilibria under both monopoly and social planning; (ii) the product price is increasing (decreasing) in the effort for quality improvement in the beginning (ending) period of the time horizon, while the price is always decreasing in the effort for marginal production cost reduction; (iii) in the neighbourhood of consumers' memory parameter, the two dimensions of R&D portfolio are substitutes (complements) if and only if the signal effect of the price is strong (weak); (iv) the change rates of the efforts in product and process R&D are increasing (decreasing) in memory parameter if and only if the signal effect of the price is below (above) some threshold; (v) by examining the extreme case of key parameters, we find that the system cannot converge to the steady-state equilibrium when consumers' adjustment speed about reference quality is low under both monopoly and social planning.
Influence of Online Reviews on the Dynamics of Product Quality and Pricing in a Competitive Market

Cui Zhao,Xiaoshuai Peng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10864415.2023.2226899

IF: 7.73

2023-07-10

International Journal of Electronic Commerce

Abstract:We study dynamic quality and pricing strategies in an e-platform with firm competition and online reviews by developing a two-period game-theoretical model. The results show that in equilibrium, online reviews lead to low selling prices in the early period but high product prices in the later selling period. On the side of equilibrium quality, online reviews will result in increased or reduced quality relying on the potential market size. Further, we examine the profit potential of the dynamic quality and/or dynamic price competition strategies. We find that the single dynamic quality competition strategy will always decrease profits of the firms. Regarding the single dynamic price competition strategy, it will increase profits of the rival firms with a large potential market size. Moreover, with a relatively large potential market size, the hybrid dynamic competition (dynamic quality and dynamic price competition) strategy is more likely to outperform the static competition strategy financially. Furthermore, we extend our model to examine how the quality and price strategies and the profit potential of dynamic competition strategies will change in the case of unit variable costs. We show from the extended analysis that in our setting, incorporating variable production costs does not alter the main findings of our research. The findings provide a decision-making framework for firms in choosing the initial and updated quality and price competition strategies with customer reviews.

business,computer science, software engineering
Better Product Quality May Lead to Lower Product Price

Regis Chenavaz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/bejte-2015-0062

2017-01-01

The B E Journal of Theoretical Economics

Abstract:This article analyzes the conditions under which better product quality implies higher or lower product price. In an optimal control framework, I make the following assumptions: The firm sets the dynamic pricing and product innovation policies; product innovation raises quality, which drives production cost, and consumers are sensitive to price and quality. I derive a rule of price-quality relationship that stresses the influence of quality on price through the effects of cost (positive), sales (negative), and markup (positive). This article shows that, while maximizing profit and despite a quality and cost increases, the firm may decrease product prices because of the possibility of generating more sales as a result of combining better quality with lower price. This sales effect solves the puzzle of a negative price-quality relationship. More generally, the sales effect mitigates the ability of price to convey information about quality.
Quality of an experience good: the interaction of price and advertising as a determining factor

Ricardo Sellers-Rubio,Francisco Mas-Ruiz,Fernando Campayo-Sanchez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14783363.2022.2112515

2022-08-18

Abstract:This paper analyses the product quality in terms of its price and company's advertising investment. The central assumption is that the advertising investment of a collective brand member has a positive influence on its product quality until an advertising investment threshold is reached, after which the effect on product quality becomes negative. This change in the slope is explained because consumers perceive advertising effort as excessive, so they wonder if this means there's a problem with the quality of the product. Advertising investment is curvilinearly related to product quality with a higher slope for products with low price than for those with high price, and positively related to products with moderate price. The results obtained from a sample of Spanish companies that operate in an experience goods industry (i.e. wineries) evidence the proposed relationships. These results reveal the importance of advertising investment for product quality in industries in which the signal of quality is not only reliant on the collective and individual brands; and also suggest the complexities of implementing such investment to get product quality in companies depending on their price.

management
Dynamic Pricing, Product and Process Innovation.

Regis Chenavaz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2012.05.009

IF: 6.4

2012-01-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:The question of simultaneous dynamic pricing, product and process investment policies is crucial for manufacturing and high-tech industries. This paper models these policies in an optimal control setting. On the supply side, the firm sets prices, product and process investment levels over time. On the demand side, current demand depends on price and quality. Under an additive separable demand function, dynamic pricing increases with quality and cost. Therefore, both product innovation and process innovation impact the pricing policy. Under a multiplicative separable demand function, dynamic pricing policy follows the dynamic of production cost and is independent of the evolution of product quality. Thus, process innovation is the main determinant of a firm’s pricing policy over time and product innovation has no impact.
Joint Dynamic Pricing and Marketing-Mix Strategies for Revenue Management Applications with Stochastic Demand

Rainer Schlosser,Regis Y. Chenavaz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/itor.13352

IF: 3.61

2023-01-01

International Transactions in Operational Research

Abstract:To attract potential customers and to effectively sell their inventories over time, retailers often invest in different marketing levers and apply dynamic pricing strategies. However, composing a profitable marketing mix in dynamic settings is challenging. The high problem complexity increases further if one seeks to account for stochastic and inventory-dependent demand, which is essential for various practical applications. In this paper, we examine such stochastic dynamic pricing and marketing models under a finite as well as an infinite time horizon. We assume that marketing dimensions, such as information advertising, design quality, and the like, are substitutes only if they are all positive; otherwise, the demand vanishes. For a reasonably general demand formulation with asymmetric multidimensions marketing, we show how to transform the multidimensional optimal control problem into a two-dimensional one, simplifying the analytical complexity. Further, for well-established cases with isoelastic and exponential demand, we present optimal closed-form solutions allowing detailed sensitivity analyses. Using numerical examples, we illustrate and analyze how optimally controlled sales processes are influenced by different model parameters and infer managerial insights. Our results provide general qualitative and quantitative insights into the complex interplay of marketing-mix controls over time.
Dynamic Vs. Static Pricing in A Supply Chain with Advertising

Jianxiong Zhang,Liyan Lei,Shichen Zhang,Lijun Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2017.05.006

IF: 7.18

2017-01-01

Computers & Industrial Engineering

Abstract:With the rapid development of e-commerce, dynamic pricing, as a powerful tool to enhance company profits, has been widely adopted by companies worldwide. However, there are little researches which focus on the effects of dynamic pricing on supply chain performance. Noting that compared with the traditional retailer, it is easier for online retailer to implement dynamic pricing strategy, we consider a Stackelberg game between one manufacturer and one online retailer where the manufacturer, as the leader, decides the advertising effort and the wholesale price, and the online retailer, as the follower, sets the retail price. Specifically, the manufacturer simultaneously faces with the online retailer and an exogenous traditional distribution channel where both the wholesale price and the retail price are fixed and exogenous. Solving this differential game, we can obtain the equilibrium strategies. The results show that if the manufacturer prices dynamically, the manufacturer itself will be better off; however, the double marginalization will be aggravated, which is adverse to supply chain efficiency. In addition, the supply chain efficiency is the lowest when both the manufacturer and the online retailer price statically, and, interestingly, it is the highest when only the online retailer prices dynamically. Moreover, if the manufacturer prices uniformly, the equilibrium strategies of the manufacturer are independent of the pricing mode of the online retailer, i.e., static or dynamic. Additionally, dynamic pricing to some extent restricts the advertising investment.
Dynamic Pricing with Reference Price Dependence

Regis Chenavaz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5018/economics-ejournal.ja.2016-22

2016-01-01

ECONOMICS

Abstract:Abstract A firm that accounts for consumer behavior sets the selling price of a product considering the reference price of consumers. In the literature, a reference price is usually modeled as depending on past selling prices. That is, past selling prices implicitly constrain the current selling price of a product. In this article, the author explicitly measures this constraint with an optimal control framework. He works on the structural properties of a general demand function, which depends on both selling and reference prices. Analytical results prove the following claims. Adjusting reference prices effects increase the price elasticity of demand, the demand function becoming flatter. Thus, the reference price effect weakens the market power of the firm. Also, the reference price effect constitutes a main driver of the dynamics of the selling price. But contrary to intuition, selling price dynamics does not systematically imitate reference price dynamics.
A Stochastic Dynamic Pricing and Advertising Model Under Risk Aversion

Rainer Schlosser

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2566930

2015-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper analyzes a dynamic pricing and advertising model for the sale of perishable products under constant absolute risk aversion. We consider a time-dependent version of Gallego and van Ryzin’s (1994) model with advertising effects, accounting for marginal unit costs. We derive closed-form expressions of the optimal risk-averse pricing and advertising policies of the value function and of the certainty equivalent. The formulas provide insight into the (complex) interplay between risk-sensitive pricing and advertising decisions. Moreover, to evaluate the optimally controlled sales process over time we propose efficient simulation techniques. These are used to analyze the characteristics of different degrees of risk aversion, particularly the concentration of the profit distribution and the impact on the expected evolution of price and advertising rates.
A joint dynamic pricing and advertising model of perishable products

Lin Feng,Jianxiong Zhang,Wansheng Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/jors.2014.89

IF: 3.6

2015-08-01

Journal of the Operational Research Society

Abstract:Advertising and dynamic pricing play key roles in maximizing profit of a firm. In this paper a joint dynamic pricing and advertising problem for perishable products is investigated, where the time-varying demand rate is decreasing in sales price and increasing in goodwill. A dynamic optimization model is proposed to maximize total profit by setting a joint pricing and advertising policy under the constraint of a limited advertising capacity. By solving the dynamic optimization problem on the basis of Pontryagin’s maximum principle, the analytical solutions of the optimal joint dynamic pricing and advertising policy are obtained. Additionally, to highlight the advantage of the joint dynamic strategy, the case of the optimal advertising with static pricing policy is considered. Numerical examples are presented to illustrate the validness of the theoretical results, and some managerial implications for the pricing and advertising of the perishable products are provided.

management,operations research & management science

Modeling the impact of product quality on dynamic pricing and advertising policies

Dynamic Pricing, Reference Price, and Price-Quality Relationship

An analytical model of the relationship between product quality and advertising.

On dynamic policies for quality, price and advertising

Dynamic Quality Policies with Reference Quality Effects

Dynamic optimal control policy in advertising price and quality

Dynamic pricing , product innovation , and quality-based cost

A Joint Dynamic Pricing and Multi-Channel Advertising Model with Stochastic Demand

Dynamic Pricing and Advertising with Demand Learning

A dynamic advertising model with reference price effect

Quality Improvement and Pricing with Reference Quality Effect

Dynamic pricing and product/process r&d with reference quality effect in a monopoly

Influence of Online Reviews on the Dynamics of Product Quality and Pricing in a Competitive Market

Better Product Quality May Lead to Lower Product Price

Quality of an experience good: the interaction of price and advertising as a determining factor

Dynamic Pricing, Product and Process Innovation.

Joint Dynamic Pricing and Marketing-Mix Strategies for Revenue Management Applications with Stochastic Demand

Dynamic Vs. Static Pricing in A Supply Chain with Advertising

Dynamic Pricing with Reference Price Dependence

A Stochastic Dynamic Pricing and Advertising Model Under Risk Aversion

A joint dynamic pricing and advertising model of perishable products