A meta-analysis of the outcomes of posterior long-segment ifxation with different upper instrumented vertebrae for degenerative lumbar scoliosis
Ke-jie ZHANG,Qi-xin CHEN,Fang-cai LI,Gang CHEN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.2095-252X.2015.03.006
2015-01-01
Abstract:Objective To investigate the clinical outcomes of posterior long-segment ifxation with different upper instrumented vertebrae for degenerative lumbar scoliosis based on a meta-analysis. Methods Computer retrieval was performed on Cochrane Library ( 8th Quarter 2014 ), Pubmed ( 1966 to August, 2014 ), Embase ( 1966 to August, 2014 ), China Biological Medicine Database ( 1978 to August, 2014 ), Wanfang database ( 1998 to August, 2014 ), China National Knowledge Internet ( CNKI ) ( 1999 to August, 2014 ) and VIP ( 1998 to August, 2014 ). Manual searching of “The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery”, “Chinese Journal of Orthopeadics” and “Chinese Journal of Spine and Spinal Cord”was also carried out. Literatures were selected, data were extracted and qualities were evaluated by 2 reviewers independently with a designed extraction form. RevMan 5.2 software was used for the meta-analysis. Results Six retrospective studies involving 453 patients were included. There were 208 patients with the fusion from the upper thoracic ( UT ) spine ( above T10 ) to L5 or S1 ( UT group ) and 245 patients with the fusion from the lower thoracic ( LT ) spine ( below T10 ) to L5 or S1 ( LT group ). The meta-analysis results were stated as following. The operation time [ weighted mean difference ( WMD )=0.94, 95%conifdence interval ( CI ) ( 0.50, 1.38 ), P<0.0001 ] was longer and the intraoperative bleeding amount [ WMD=0.60, 95%CI ( 0.34, 0.86 ), P<0.00001 ] was more in UT group than that in LT group. While there were not statistically signiifcant differences betwee the 2 groups in postoperative Oswestry Disability Index ( ODI ) [ WMD=0.83, 95%CI (-3.45, 5.10 ), P=0.70 ], postoperative lumbar lordosis ( LL ) [ WMD=-0.94, 95%CI (-3.39, 5.27 ), P=0.67 ], postoperative proximal junctional kyphosis ( PJK ) [ WMD=-1.93, 95% CI ( -4.65, 0.79, P=0.16 ], postoperative sagittal vertical axis ( SVA ) [ WMD=-1.13, 95% CI (-4.19, 1.92 ), P=0.47 ] and postoperative thoracic kyphosis ( TK ) [ WMD=1.51, 95%CI (-2.76, 55.78 ), P=0.49 ]. Conclusions Fusion from the lower thoracic spine ( below T10 ) is as effective as the fusion from the upper thoracic spine ( above T10 ) in posterior long-segment ifxation for degenerative lumbar scoliosis, with the advantages of shorter operation time and less blood loss. In addition spinal sagittal deformity correction can be improved.