Sex differences in the magnitude of statural gains of offspring over parents.
T. Bielicki,J. Charzewski
1977-09-01
Abstract:Differences in adult stature between offspring and same-sexed parent were analyzed in 496 Polish families having a total of 478 daughters and 542 sons. All parent-offspring comparisons were divided into two categories: "advancing" lineages, in which an upward shift in educational status has occured between the grandparents and parents, and "stable" lineages, in which no such shift has taken place. The average statural gain of son over father was 2.21% in "stable" lineages, and 2.88% in "advancing" lineages; in contrast, daughter-mother comparisons yield mean percentual gains of 1.14 and 1.37, respectively. These findings are interpreted as a direct verification f the hypothesis that, with regard to growth in size, boys tend to respond to environmental improvement more dramatically than do girls; and, in broader terms, as further vidence for the higher eco-sensitivi ty of developmental processes in the male. Since Greuliche classic study in 1947 of the islanders of Guam, and his observation that war-conditioned evelopmental retardations, though detectable in local children of both sexes, were in all respects more severe in boys than in girls (Greulich, 1951) there has been an increasing body of evidence indicating that females, as compared to males, are less easily thrown off their growth pathway by environmental adversities such as malnutrition or disease. Support for this hypothesis comes from a variety of observations on growth in size, skeketal maturation, and dental eruption. For example, the extensive dental data published by Charzewski (1963) clearly show that in Poland in the early 1960's rural girls compared with urban girls were less retarded in eruption of permanent teeth than were rural boys compared with urban boys. A general discussion of the problem, and a review of the evidence, can be found in Tanner (1962, pp. 127-128). The buffering of a developmental process against environmental stresses has been termed by Waddington (1957) homeorhesis or canalization; these concepts denote the capacity of an individual, or an organ, to attain "some particular end-state in spite of temporary deviations on the way there" (Waddington 1957, p. 42), or the capacity to maintain the institute of Anthropology, Polish Academy of Sciences, Wroclaw, Poland. 2Department of Anthropology, Academy of Physical Education, Warsaw, Poland. Human Biology, September 1977, Vol. 49, No. 3, pp. 265-277. ° Wayne State University Press, 1977 266 Tadeusz Bielicki and Janusz Charzewski phenotype on a particular, deviation-resistant developmental trajectory "all the way through," i.e. from a certain early stage of development up to and including the mature stage. Now, if males have indeed less power for homeorhesis such sex difference should be manifest in both "negative" and "positive" effects; i.e. boys, compared to girls, can be expected not only to suffer more from environmental vicissitudes but also to respond more dramatically to environmental improvement. Specifically, secular increases in adult stature (if, as generally assumed, caused primarily by environmental betterment) should be more marked in males than in females. This expectation is confirmed by some cross-sectional surveys, e.g. by the findings of Tobias (1962) on the African Bushmen, and of Mróz (1975), and Milicer, Skíad, and Skibiñska (1976) on several samples of the urban population of Poland. Of particular relevance in the present context is the study of Acheson and Fowler (1964) who employed family materials, rather than the usual procedure of analyzing a time-series of population means, and examined the pattern of statural gains of offspring over parents. In this investigation we use a similar approach, but we try to relate statural gains to environmental changes in a more direct manner. Specifically, we are concerned with the following question: If inter-generation improvement (versus stability) of socio-economic onditions in the family has an effect on the magnitude of statural gains of offspring over samesexed parent then is this effect greater in sons than in daughters? Materials and Methods The study group consists of 496 Polish families with at least one grown-up child; it comprises, in addition to the parental pairs, a total of 478 daughters and 542 sons. About 75% of these families were drawn from Siedlce, a town of 45,000 inhabitants, 80 km east of Warsaw, the rest from the city of Warsaw. No specific sampling procedures were used, because in this study, involving only within-family and between-sex comparisons, it is of little relevance to what extent the subjects constitute a representative sample of any particular region of the country, or of any specific socio-economic stratum. It may only be noted that 1. the material is ethnically homogenous, and 2. the Siedlce families were recruited with the help of the headmaster of a local vocational high school (Technicum); they are mainly families of the school s teachers and pupils, or those of the pupil's acquaintances, neighbors, etc. However, the only criterion for inclusion of a family in the study group was age at the time of examination, (May-June 1975): no parent older than 55 years, sons at least 18, Sex Differences and Statural Gains 267 daughters at least 17 years old. The material therefore represents two practically non-overlapping birth cohorts: the majority of parents were born in the 1920 s, with no parent born later than 1938, while 96% of the children were born later than 1945, the oldest child in the sample being born in 1938. Thus, almost all children in this material belong to the generation of the Polish post-war baby-boom. In each family information was collected on the educational and occupational status of parents and of grandparents; the composition of the parental generation in terms of these two criteria is given in Table 1. On