Abstract:As the online channel is crucially important, traditional offline retail stores seek to induce their existing consumers to buy online with incentives (i.e., offline-to-online targeting). However, it is debatable whether such targeting is truly effective. While advocates argue that online shopping should complement a firm's store channel, critics counter that doing so may result in cannibalization. Drawing on the channel interplay literature and considering customers' travel costs, we examine whether and how inducing online shopping complements or cannibalizes a firm's offline sales. Using a randomized field experiment on over 11,200 customers of a large department store, we provide causal evidence for both the complementarity and cannibalization effects of online and offline channels. Offline-to-online targeting engenders higher online purchases (as intended) than no targeting. The local average treatment effects models suggest that once induced to buy online, consumers who live near the retailer's physical store tend to increase their offline spending and total sales by 47% (i.e., complementarity effects for nearby consumers). However, for consumers who live far away from the brick-and-mortar store, inducing them to buy online can backfire by reducing offline and total sales by approximately 5.7% for each additional kilometer of distance (i.e., cannibalization effects for distant consumers). Explorations of these mechanisms suggest that distant consumers who are induced to buy online may fail to return to shop in the offline store and purchase less experiential category products with a smaller basket size than other customers, thus leading to a negative net impact on the total sales. These findings alert managers to the dangers of improper targeting and investment in information technology and the importance of consumer heterogeneity for omnichannel commerce across online and offline channels.

When and How to Leverage E-commerce Cart Targeting: the Relative and Moderated Effects of Scarcity and Price Incentives with a Two-Stage Field Experiment and Causal Forest Optimization.

Targeted Promotions on an E-Book Platform: Crowding Out, Heterogeneity, and Opportunity Costs

Targeted Promotions and Cross-Category Spillover Effects

Complementarity and Cannibalization of Offline-to-Online Targeting: A Field Experiment on Omnichannel Commerce

The Double-Edged Effects of E-Commerce Cart Retargeting: Does Too Early Retargeting Backfire?

Enhancing geotargeting with temporal targeting, behavioral targeting and promotion for comprehensive contextual targeting.

The Double-Edged Effects of E-Commerce Cart Retargeting: Does Retargeting Too Early Backfire?

The Effectiveness of Contextual Competitive Targeting in Conjunction with Promotional Incentives.

Segment Discovery: Enhancing E-commerce Targeting

A Profit-Maximizing Strategy for Advertising on the e-Commerce Platforms

EXTR: Click-Through Rate Prediction with Externalities in E-Commerce Sponsored Search

The Impact of Increasing Search Frictions on Online Shopping Behavior: Evidence from a Field Experiment

Is Combining Contextual and Behavioral Targeting Strategies Effective in Online Advertising?

Estimating Assortment Size Effects on Platforms: Leveraging Imperfect Geographic Targeting for Causal Inference

Estimating Individual Advertising Effect in E-Commerce

How Precious Are Scarce Products? an Experimental Study on a Turn-and-Earn Allocation Mechanism

Targeting customers under response-dependent costs

Consumer Search and Purchase: an Empirical Investigation of Retargeting Based on Consumer Online Behaviors.

Why Do Some Consumers Still Prefer In-Store Shopping? An Exploration of Online Shopping Cart Abandonment Behavior

Tracking the Luxury Consumer Online: an Experimental Study on the Effectiveness of Site and Search Retargeting for Luxury Brands in China and the Netherlands: an Abstract

Prefer cheap or expensive products? Shopping stage matters