Abstract:The integration of Multi-Objective Optimization (MOO) and Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) has gathered significant attention across various scientific research domains to facilitate integrated sustainability assessment. Recently, there has been a growing interest in hybrid approaches that combine MCDM with MOO, aiming to enhance the efficacy of the final decisions. However, a critical gap exists in terms of providing clear methodological guidance, particularly when dealing with data uncertainties. To address this gap, this systematic review is designed to develop a generic decision tree that serves as a practical roadmap for practitioners seeking to perform MOO and MCDM in an integrated fashion, with a specific focus on accounting for uncertainties. The systematic review identified the recent studies that conducted both MOO and MCDM in an integrated way. It is important to note that this review does not aim to identify the superior MOO or MCDM methods, but rather it delves into the strategies for integrating these two common methodologies. The prevalent MOO methods used in the reviewed articles were evolution-based metaheuristic methods. TOPSIS and PROMETHEE II are the prevalent MCDM ranking methods. The integration of MOO and MCDM methods can occur either a priori, a posteriori, or through a combination of both, each offering distinct advantages and drawbacks. The developed decision tree illustrated all three paths and integrated uncertainty considerations in each path. Finally, a real-world case study for the pulse fractionation process in Canada is used as a basis for demonstrating the various pathways presented in the decision tree and their application in identifying the optimized processing pathways for sustainably obtaining pulse protein. This study will help practitioners in different research domains use MOO and MCDM methods in an integrated way to identify the most sustainable and optimized system.

Decision-Making for Sustainability Enhancement of Chemical Systems under Uncertainties: Combining the Vector-Based Multiattribute Decision-Making Method with Weighted Multiobjective Optimization Technique

Machine learning aided multi-objective optimization and multi-criteria decision making: Framework and two applications in chemical engineering

Development of a Generic Decision Tree for the Integration of Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) and Multi-Objective Optimization (MOO) Methods under Uncertainty to Facilitate Sustainability Assessment: A Methodical Review

Data-mechanism-driven Product Performance Optimization with Multiple Parameters under Uncertainties in Manufacturing Automation Systems

An integrated approach for multi-objective optimisation and MCDM of energy internet under uncertainty

Uncertainty-Based Multi-Objective Decision Making with Hierarchical Reliability Analysis under Water Resources and Environmental Constraints

Analysis of Weighting and Selection Methods for Pareto-Optimal Solutions of Multiobjective Optimization in Chemical Engineering Applications

Multiactor Multicriteria Decision Making for Life Cycle Sustainability Assessment under Uncertainties

A Decision Support Model for Multi-Attribute Group Decision Making Using a Multi-Objective Optimization Approach.

Multi-objective optimization and decision making for integrated energy system using STA and fuzzy TOPSIS

Sensitivity Assessment of Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Methods in Chemical Engineering Optimization Applications

A Performance-Oriented Optimization Framework Combining Meta-Heuristics and Entropy-Weighted TOPSIS for Multi-Objective Sustainable Supply Chain Network Design

Proposal of a multi-expert multi-criteria model for the sustainability assessment of industrial systems under uncertainty

A Novel Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Framework for Selecting Municipal Solid Waste Management Alternative with 2-Dimensional Uncertain Linguistic Sets

Sustainability Prioritization of CCUS Systems with Consideration of Criteria Interaction: a Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Framework Based on 2-Additive Fuzzy Measure and Choquet Integral Method

A novel multi-objective optimization framework for optimal integrated energy system planning with demand response under multiple uncertainties

A Two-Stage Multi-Objective Optimization and Decision-Making Method for Integrated Energy System under Wind Disturbances

A Novel Multi-Attribute Group Decision-Making Method Based on the MULTIMOORA with Linguistic Evaluations

Integrated Decision-Making Method for Heterogeneous Attributes Based on Probabilistic Linguistic Cross-Entropy and Priority Relations

Sustainability Assessment and Decision Making of Hydrogen Production Technologies: A Novel Two-Stage Multi-Criteria Decision Making Method

New Optimization Framework for Improvement Sustainability of Wastewater Treatment Plants