Abstract:A model fit by general estimating equations (GEE) has been used extensively for the analysis of longitudinal data in medical studies. To some extent, GEE tries to minimize a quadratic form of the residuals, and therefore is not robust in the sense that it, like least squares estimates, is sensitive to heavy-tailed distributions, contaminated distributions and extreme values. This paper describes the family of truncated robust estimating equations and its properties for the analysis of quantitative longitudinal data. Like GEE, the robust estimating equations aim to assess the covariate effects in the generalized linear model in the complete population of observations, but in a manner that is more robust to the influence of aberrant observations. A simulation study has been conducted to compare the finite-sample performance of GEE and the robust estimating equations under a variety of error distributions and data structures. It shows that the parameter estimates based on GEE and the robust estimating equations are approximately unbiased and the type I errors of Wald tests do not tend to be inflated. GEE is slightly more efficient with pure normal data, but the efficiency of GEE declines much more quickly than the robust estimating equations when the data become contaminated or have heavy tails, which makes the robust estimating equations advantageous with non-normal data. Both GEE and the robust estimating equations are applied to a longitudinal analysis of renal function in the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial (DCCT). For this application, GEE seems to be sensitive to the working correlation specification in that different working correlation structures may lead to different conclusions about the effect of intensive diabetes treatment. On the other hand, the robust estimating equations consistently conclude that the treatment effect is highly significant no matter which working correlation structure is used. The DCCT Research Group also demonstrated a significant effect using a mixed-effects longitudinal model.

Robust estimation of generalized estimating equations with finite mixture correlation matrices and missing covariates at random for longitudinal data

Conditional Mix-Gee Models for Longitudinal Data with Unspecified Random-Effects Distributions

Multiply robust generalized estimating equations for cluster randomized trials with missing outcomes

Robust Statistical Inference for Longitudinal Data with Nonignorable Dropouts

Doubly Robust-Based Generalized Estimating Equations for the Analysis of Longitudinal Ordinal Missing Data

An Efficient Multiple Imputation Approach for Estimating Equations with Response Missing at Random and High-Dimensional Covariates

Weighted Estimating Equation: Modified GEE in Longitudinal Data Analysis

Robust Estimation in Generalized Semiparametric Mixed Models for Longitudinal Data

Application of robust estimating equations to the analysis of quantitative longitudinal data

Robust estimation in joint mean–covariance regression model for longitudinal data

Modeling of mean-covariance structures in generalized estimating equations with dropouts

Generalized Partial Linear Models with Nonignorable Dropouts

Robust empirical likelihood inference for generalized partial linear models with longitudinal data

Bayesian estimation in generalized linear models for longitudinal data with hyperspherical coordinates

Robust Estimating Equations and Bias Correction of Correlation Parameters for Longitudinal Data

Covariance Estimators for Generalized Estimating Equations (GEE) in Longitudinal Analysis with Small Samples

Robust estimation of covariance parameters in partial linear model for longitudinal data☆

Improved Empirical Likelihood Inference and Variable Selection for Generalized Linear Models with Longitudinal Nonignorable Dropouts

Robust Estimation in Partial Linear Mixed Model for Longitudinal Data

An Efficient and Robust Variable Selection Method for Longitudinal Generalized Linear Models

Robust estimation of the generalised partial linear model with missing covariates