Abstract:Objective To compare the efects between different tympanoplasty techniques for chdesteatoma. Methods 38 cases(ears) who were operated on between Jan., 2002 and Apr., 2003 were served as group A(25 male , 13 female ; age: 13-72 years). They had been followed up for 12-28 months postoperatively, with an average of 18.56 months. Of the 38cases, 6 have had a relapse after an operation performed in our or other hospitals 1-6 years ago. Other 38 cases (40 ears) who were operated on between Apr., 1995 and Dec., 1999 were served as group B(17 male, 21 female; age: 9-60 years). They had been followed up for 6-110 months (mean 17.12 months). Of them, 5 were recurrent cases. The two groups were comparable in the air conduction (AC) and air bone gap (ABG) values , and had no difference statistically. The operative method in group A was based on a combination of verious techniques, including lateral attic wall reconstruction (scute repair), chorda tympani nerve tightening prosthesis, and prevention of adhesion formation by a absobable membrane. In group B, tympanoplasty with modified mastoidectomy was performed. The audiological data obtained from the last follow-up in the two groups were used for statistical analysis (student’s t test). Results The postoperative AC and ABG and the ABG differences between pre-and post-operation in group A were 27.05±12.53, 12.89±8.08 and 22.34±11.92, respectively. The counterparts in group B were 42.76±14.22, 22.27±10.95 and 8.83±8.72, respectively. All the differences between them were statistically significant(P0.01). Group A had re-perforation of the tympanic membrane in 4 cases (10.5%) during the follow-up time. Of them 3 cases received a revision operation and only one ear had cholesteatoma remnants(2.6%). In Gyoup B, however, there were 9 cases(22.5%) who received a revision operation for recurrent cholesteatoma. Conclusion A combination of various operation procedures for cholesteatoma adopted in this study had evident advantages in prevent of recurrent cholesteatoma and improvement of hearing outcome.

[Comparison of the Treatment Effect for Stage Ⅰepitympanic Cholesteatoma with Atticotomy and Bondy Modified Radical Mastoidectomy].

A Comparison of the Effects Between Different Tympanoplasty Techniques for Cholesteatoma

Analysis of surgical methods and outcome of middle ear cholesteatuma

Comparison of the Clinical Results of Attic Cholesteatoma Treatment: Endoscopic Versus Microscopic Ear Surgery

[Analyses of the Operative Efficacy of 102 Cases of Acquired Middle Ear Cholesteatoma].

Clinical characteristics and surgical management of middle ear cholesteatoma in children

Comparison of Total Endoscopic Ear Surgery and Microscopic Postauricular Canal-Wall-Down Approach on Primary Acquired Cholesteatoma

Intact canal wall mastoidectomy and tympanoplasty in treating patients with cholesteatoma of the middle ear and mastoid]

Attic reconstruction techniques in cholesteatoma surgery: a comparative analysis of cartilage versus bone pate

Clinical observation of external canal reconstruction with autogenous bone pate in the micro-otosurgery

Prognostic Factors of Hearing Improvement for EES and MES in Attic Cholesteatoma

[Surgical Treatment of External Auricular Cholesteatoma Involving Tympanum and Papilloma].

Management of Ear Canal Cholesteatoma with Otitis Media

Combined Flap of Postauricular Musculo-Periosteal and Ear Canal Skin Flap with Bone Paté for Mastoid Obliteration and Canal Wall Down Mastoidectomy

Analysis of reoperations after radical mastoidectomy

Modificatory Method of Management for the Open Mastoid Cavity and the Opening of External Acoustic Meatus

Comparison of the Impacts of Different Middle Ear Mucosal Conditions on Type I Tympanoplasty Outcomes

Clinical Application of Attic Reconstruction and Tympanoplasty for Operated Ears with Open Radical Mastoidectomy

The Effects of the Plasty of the Cavity of Auricular Concha in the Post-Mastoidectomy

The Outcomes Of Endoscopic Approach For Attic Cholesteatoma: Underwater Continuous Drilling Versus Traditional Intermittent Drilling

Application of Autologous Bone Meal and Temporalis Fascia in Middle Ear and Mastoid Surgery