Abstract:Numerous quantitative ultrasound imaging techniques have demonstrated superior monitoring performance for thermal ablation when compared to conventional ultrasonic B-mode imaging. However, the absence of comparative studies involving various quantitative ultrasound imaging techniques hinders further clinical exploration. In this study, we simultaneously reconstructed ultrasonic Nakagami imaging, ultrasonic horizontally normalized Shannon entropy (hNSE) imaging, and ultrasonic differential attenuation coefficient intercept (DACI) imaging from ultrasound backscattered envelope data collected during high-intensity focused ultrasound ablation treatment. We comprehensively investigated their performance differences through qualitative and quantitative analyses, including the calculation of contrast-to-noise ratios (CNR) for ultrasonic images, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis with corresponding indicators, the analysis of lesion area fitting relationships, and computational time consumption comparison. The mean CNR of hNSE imaging was 10.98 ± 4.48 dB, significantly surpassing the 3.82 ± 1.40 dB (p < 0.001, statistically significant) of Nakagami imaging and the 2.45 ± 0.74 dB (p < 0.001, statistically significant) of DACI imaging. This substantial difference underscores that hNSE imaging offers the highest contrast resolution for lesion recognition. Furthermore, we evaluated the ability of multiple ultrasonic parametric imaging to detect thermal ablation lesions using ROC curves. The area under the curve (AUC) for hNSE was 0.874, exceeding the values of 0.848 for Nakagami imaging and 0.832 for DACI imaging. Additionally, hNSE imaging exhibited the strongest linear correlation coefficient (R = 0.92) in the comparison of lesion area fitting, outperforming Nakagami imaging (R = 0.87) and DACI imaging (R = 0.85). hNSE imaging also performs best in real-time monitoring with each frame taking 6.38 s among multiple ultrasonic parametric imaging. Our findings unequivocally demonstrate that hNSE imaging excels in monitoring HIFU ablation treatment and holds the greatest potential for further clinical exploration.

Assessment of Nakagami Parameters of Ultrasonic Harmonic Envelopes for Noninvasive Microwave Ablation Monitoring

Monitoring of Microwave Ablation in Porcine Liver Using Ultrasonic Nakagami Imaging

A Systemic Study on the Performance of Different Quantitative Ultrasound Imaging Techniques for Microwave Ablation Monitoring of Liver

Application study of using ultrasonic integral backscatter to monitor microwave coagulation therapy

[An in Vivo Study of Ultrasonic Monitoring Imaging of Microwave Ablation Based on Nakagami Statistic Parameter].

Microwave Ablation Monitoring Based on Automatic Segmentation of Ultrasonic Harmonic Envelope Nakagami Parametric Imaging

Monitoring microwave ablation using ultrasound homodyned K imaging based on the noise-assisted correlation algorithm: An <i>ex vivo</i> study

Ex Vivo and in Vivo Monitoring and Characterization of Thermal Lesions by High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound and Microwave Ablation Using Ultrasonic Nakagami Imaging

A Clinical Study of Thermal Monitoring Techniques of Ultrasound-Guided Microwave Ablation for Hepatocellular Carcinoma in High-Risk Locations

Ultrasound Entropy Imaging for Detection and Monitoring of Thermal Lesion During Microwave Ablation of Liver.

Some Thermal Problems in Microwave Ablation Therapy for Hepatocellular Carcinoma

Experimental Study for Noninvasive Monitoring of Hyperthermia Based on Features of Ultrasonic Echo

Research Progress of Noninvasive Monitoring Methods for Tumor Hyperthermia Based on Ultrasonic Tissue Characterization

Fast Ultrasonic Ablation Monitoring: an Innovative Approach Using Ultrasound RF Signals and Singular Value Decomposition

Monitoring Microwave Ablation Using Ultrasound Echo Decorrelation Imaging: an Ex Vivo Study

Evaluate Thermal Lesion Using Nakagami Imaging for Monitoring of High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound

In Vivo Monitoring Of Microwave Ablation In A Porcine Model Using Ultrasonic Differential Attenuation Coefficient Intercept Imaging

Feasibility of Using Ultrasonic Nakagami Imaging for Monitoring Microwave-Induced Thermal Lesion in Ex Vivo Porcine Liver

Advances in noninvasive monitoring of thermal therapy with ultrasound elasticity imaging

Multiple ultrasonic parametric imaging for the detection and monitoring of high-intensity focused ultrasound ablation

Multimodality quantitative ultrasound envelope statistics imaging based support vector machines for characterizing tissue scatterer distribution patterns: Methods and application in detecting microwave-induced thermal lesions