Management Scholars’ Learning from History: Direct Vs. Indirect Approach

Runtian Jing,Mei Dong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/mor.2017.59
IF: 3.776
2017-01-01
Management and Organization Review
Abstract:We appreciate this invitation to comment on the paper on Western perceptions of Chinese culture, to provide an insider perspective. Because of its unique perspective on Chinese historical teachings, the study reminds us about the challenges in learning and applying indigenous knowledge. For example, it compares the lens of war and business in many dimensions, such as a focus on an enemy (war) or on customers (business), a matter of life and death (war) or not (business), one competitor (war) or a number of competitors (business), deception (war) or secrecy (business), or a one-time relationship (war) or a long-term relationship (business). The paper offers us a striking warning about the risk of overdrawing historical analogies in management research.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?