How Can Stones from Another Mountain Be Used to Chisel the Local Jade——Issues and Problems Involved in Learning from Foreign Countries

Lan Zhiyong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-6162.2006.04.003

2006-01-01

Abstract:The paper reviews the lessons and experiences of China's efforts in learning from foreign countries, particularly in the past few decades. The author argues that while differences do exist between China and western countries, they are more so in terms of extent of development than by nature. They do not support the view that the west and the east can not learn from one another. Using east and west as units of analysis for comparative studies between the governance models and the trajectories of development countries on both sides is by no means a good choice. It has been in use due mostly not to theoretical considerations but to the convenience of choice and emotions. Looking back into China's history in the past one hundred years, the convenience of choice and emotions have actually hindered China effort to learn from foreign countries, and hence, should be rectified. Public administration is a modern and a relatively new field of study in China. What is most important in its learning from outside of country is what is good and appropriate for China but not what is the newest, the most foreign, and the most popular. Only when emphases of the debate have ceased to be what is west and what east, and what is old and what is new can China's international learning significantly improve. Therefore, China's intellectual community needs to alter its existing learning paradigm and think outside of the current boxes. Examples of international learning are used to illustrate the author's point of argumentation.