A study of weight making methods for agricultural land gradation evaluation
Jin Xiao-Bin,Zhang Hong-Hui,Zhou Yin-Kang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:0469-5097.2008.04.017
2008-01-01
Abstract:Agriculture land gradation is an important method for comprehensive agriculture land quality evaluation.It focuses on describing the difference of land output caused by the practical or possible quality of natural land and the level and efficiency of land use.The evaluation results are comparable in the county-level administrative regions.Together with agriculture land classification and appraisal,the agriculture land gradation is the key factor in national resource investigation and is always taken as a basis for the esstablishment of a unified land market and land resource allocation in China.According to the related regulations,agricultural land gradation is first calculated by weighted sum of indices.Then the gradation results are classified by equidistance,axis or sum frequency curve.Therefore,the proper method for weight making plays a critical role in agricultural land gradation process.Currently,the single or the mixed weight making methods have been applied in agricultural land gradation practices.But as far as the specific district is concerned,little attention is paid to the efficiency of the weight making methods and their quantitative differences.In this paper,we compare different weight making methods by a series of experiments.The data set is from Jintan city which is located in Jiangsu province.Considering some dominating evaluation indices,such as influence of center town,convenience of traffic,the favorableness of farming,contents of elements N,P,and K,efficiency of irrigation rate and land management level,the gradation evaluation is carried out by weighted sum of indices.Then the gradation classification is categorized by equidistance and sum frequency curve respectively.Numerical results and spatial distribution show there are obvious differences among these weight making and gradation classification methods.We suggest that these weight making methods should be combined in order to overcome the disadvantages of any particlar one.