Abstract:PurposeThis study examines how firm product reputation functions as an internal and external expectations-setting mechanism shaping firm and external stakeholder behavior.Design/methodology/approachLongitudinal analysis of 17,879 recalls from 15 automobile manufacturers operating in the United States between 1967 and 2016.FindingsApplying the behavioral theory of the firm (BTF) and signaling theory, this study’s findings suggest that product safety reputation creates variability in the likelihood of both voluntary and government-ordered recalls.Research limitations/implicationsPerformance expectations set by past product performance influence managerial decision-making such that products with a higher reputation for quality are more likely to be voluntarily recalled than are their less reputable counterparts. Similarly, regulators are more likely to order the recall of higher reputation products, suggesting that past product performance also influences enforcement behavior. Finally, the scope and severity of product defects are shown to interact with product reputation to influence the likelihood of government-ordered recall.Practical implicationsFirms and firm stakeholders make distinct decisions based on performance variations within firm product portfolios.Social implicationsOverall firm reputation is important, but there are distinct dynamics that result in product performance variability within firm product portfolios that have important implications on issues such as product safety recalls.Originality/valueThis study's findings reveal that as an internal signal, managers' expectations of product performance can change their behavior following product safety defects. Specifically, voluntary product recalls are more likely for higher-reputation products than those with lower reputations for product safety. This suggests that firm behavior regarding product safety recalls is not consistent within their own product lines. Externally, this study’s findings suggest that product reputation also influences relationships with key stakeholders. Product reputation for quality was shown to be associated with an increased likelihood of government sanctions. Regulators will also be more likely to initiate punitive sanctions against higher-reputation products as the severity and scope of safety defects increase. Under such circumstances, higher-reputation products are more likely to face government sanctions than lower-reputation products. Hence, government regulatory behavior is subject to influence from performance signals such as product reputation.

What Drives a Firm's Choice of Product Recall Remedy? the Impact of Remedy Cost, Product Hazard, and the CEO

Does a Firm's Product-Recall Strategy Affect Its Financial Value? an Examination of Strategic Alternatives During Product-Harm Crises

Dynamic Pricing and Advertising Decisions to Mitigate the Negative Spillover Effect of a Product Recall

Should Ad Spending Increase or Decrease Before a Recall Announcement? the Marketing–Finance Interface in Product-Harm Crisis Management

Impacts of Chief Marketing Officer in Product Recalls

Too Much of a Good Thing? the Boomerang Effect of Firms’ Investments on Corporate Social Responsibility During Product Recalls

Regulating Product Recall Compliance in the Digital Age: Evidence from the “Safe Cars Save Lives” Campaign

The Role of Social Media in the Capital Market: Evidence from Consumer Product Recalls

Dynamic Quality and Advertising Decisions Considering Product Recalls in Supply Chain

Does Being Socially Responsible Buffer Reputation Loss in a Product Crisis? the Moderating Role of Lay Theory of Corporate Social Responsibility

Research on the Influence of Protecting Brand Equity in the Event of Defensible Product Harm Crisis by Appropriate Remedial Response:Moderating and Mediating Effects

The Moderating Role of Power Distance on the Reaction of Consumers to the CEO as a Spokesperson During a Product Harm Crisis: Insights From China and South Korea

Attribute-based product reputation as a market signal: examining product safety recalls in the US auto industry

An Empirical Study of the Volkswagen Recall Crisis in China: Customer's Risk Perceptions and Behavior Responses Based on an Information Flow

Quality and price competition in a duopoly under product liability and traceability

When CEO Pay Becomes a Brand Problem

Spillover effect in supplier related product recall: the impact of supplier COO on product evaluations

Product Recalls as Service Failure: Revisiting Consumer Reactions

The Impact of Voluntary Recall on the Trust of Loyal and First-Time Consumers in a High Awareness Brand After a Functional Transgression

Taming the Blame Game: Using Promotion Programs to Counter Product-Harm Crises

Effect of CEO Recognition on Brand Sympathy through Consumer Product Perception: A Comparative Analysis of Japanese and U.S. Consumers