Electron conjugation versus π-π repulsion in substituted benzenes: why the carbon-nitrogen bond in nitrobenzene is longer than in aniline.

Huaiyu Zhang,Xiaoyu Jiang,Wei Wu,Yirong Mo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/c6cp00471g
IF: 3.3
2016-01-01
Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics
Abstract:Gas-phase electron diffraction experiments show that the C-N bond in aniline (1.407 angstrom) is significantly shorter than in nitrobenzene (1.486 angstrom). It is known that the amino group is electron-donating and the nitro group is electron-withdrawing, and both substitution groups can effectively conjugate with benzene. Thus, it is puzzling why the C-N bond in nitrobenzene is even longer than the single C-N bond in methylamine (1.472 angstrom). In this work, we performed computations by strictly localizing the pi electrons with the block-localized wavefunction (BLW) method, which is a variant of ab initio valence bond theory. Geometry optimizations of electron-localized states, where the conjugation over the C-N bond is quenched, show that the conjugation in nitrobenzene is only half of the conjugation in aniline. But even in optimal electron-localized states, the C-N bond in nitrobenzene is still 0.074 angstrom longer than in aniline. As a consequence, it is indeed not the pi conjugation which is responsible for the disparity of the C-N bond distances in these systems. Instead, we demonstrated that the pi-pi repulsion, which is contributed by both Pauli exchange and electrostatic interaction, plays the key role in this "abnormal" behavior. Notably, the pi resonance within the nitro group generates a considerable dipole, which repels the pi electrons in the benzene ring. The deactivation of the resonance within the nitro group significantly shortens the C-N bond by 0.06 angstrom. The unfavorable pi-pi electrostatic repulsion is further exemplified by N2O4. In fact, the destabilizing pi-pi repulsion is ubiquitous but largely neglected in conjugated systems where only the stabilizing conjugation is the focus. Experimental phenomena such as the C-N bond distances in aniline and nitrobenzene result from the balance of both stabilizing and destabilizing forces.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?