Comparisons of the Acidities and Homolytic Bond Dissociation Energies of the Acidic Nitrogen-Hydrogen and Carbon-Hydrogen Bonds in Diphenylmethanes and Carbazoles
FG BORDWELL,XM ZHANG,JP CHENG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/jo00010a009
1991-01-01
The Journal of Organic Chemistry
Abstract:The acidities and homolytic bond dissociation energies (BDEs) of the acidic H-C or H-N bonds in six alpha-substituted diphenylmethanes, Ph2CHG, nine remotely substituted diphenylamines, four bridged diphenylamines (iminodibenzyl, iminostilbene, phenothiazine, phenoxazine), three carbazoles, indole, and pyrrole are reported. The near constancy (15 +/- 2.5 kcal/mol) of the increased acidity for 9-G-fluorenes compared to alpha-G-diphenylmethanes, which represents the approximate relative aromatic stabilization energies of the fluorenide anions, indicates that electronic effects on 9-GFl- and Ph2CG- ions do not differ greatly. On the other hand, steric effects in Ph2CG. radicals cause destabilizing effects when G is SPh, CO2Et, or SO2Ph, whereas, except for SO2Ph, these functions are stabilizing in 9-GFl. radicals. The BDEs for the acidic H-C bonds in 9-substituted fluorenes, 9-GFl-H, are smaller than those in their open-chain analogues, the diphenylmethanes, Ph2C(G)-H, (G = H, Ph, SPh, CN, CO2Et, SO2Ph) by approximately 2-8 kcal/mol. In contrast, the BDEs for the H-N bonds in carbazoles are larger by 5-6 kcal than those in comparable diphenylamines. The conclusion drawn from these observations is that, whereas the odd electron in a 9-fluorenyl radical is in a p orbital parallel to the pi orbitals of the fluorene ring, the odd electron in a 9-carbazoyl radical is in a sigma orbital orthogonal to the pi orbitals of the carbazole ring. Evidence to indicate that pyrrolyl and indolyl are also sigma radicals is presented.