Self-Construal, Self-Serving Attributional Bias, and Self-Enhancement in Chinese College Students
Ma Weijun,Feng Rui
2012-01-01
Abstract:Cross-cultural research points out the discrepancies of attribution tendencies in different cultures. Westerners tend to display self-serving attribution bias (SSAB), a tendency that people attribute their success to internal causes and attribute their failure to external causes. However, people from Asian countries, such as Japan, are easy to show opposite self-effacing attribution bias. One appropriate explanation is from the viewpoint of cultural self-construals. According to the Cultural Self-Construal Theory (Markus & Kitayama, 1991), people in different cultures hold different self-construals. ‘Independent self-construal’ of Westerners addresses independence and pays attention to an individual's privacy, rights, and liberties, whereas ‘interdependent self-construal' of Asians, such as Japanese and Chinese, addresses coordination and relationships with others. Those disparate self views are reflected in Asian and Western people' thoughts, cognition, and behaviors. Due to different self-construals, Asian people and Westerners show different attribution biases. Asian people are easy to show modesty attribution tendencies because of their interdependent self-construal. Their self-enhancement is through an indirect way. Westerners tend to show SSAB and direct self-enhancement due to independent self-construals. Cultural self-construals have strong impacts on attribution biases. Furthermore, according to Takata (2000), individuals' self-construal includes the independent aspect and the interdependent aspect. It is likely that individual differences in self-construals influence the attribution tendencies. However, this impact still lacks direct experimental evidence to confirm it.This study includes an experiment to investigate the influences of individual differences of self-construal with SSAB and self-enhancement in Chinese college students. One hundred and four Chinese college students in Shanghai completed a fictitious social sensation ability test. Then, their self-construal and other attributes were measured. Finally, they made attributions about their performance and evaluated the test. The results indicated that the Chinese college students showed significant SSAB and self-enhancement in attributions and evaluations of the test. The individuals, whose independence is dominant (independent self-construal), showed a more pronounced self-enhancement than the individuals, whose interdependency is dominant (interdependent self-construal). Furthermore, there is a significant, positive correlation between independence and self-enhancement, in either a successful or failure situation, i.e., stronger the independence resulted in more notable self-enhancement. Independence plays a crucial role for self-enhancement. Interdependency is also positively correlated with self-enhancement, especially in the failure situation. The results of this study indicated that individual differences of self-construal significantly influenced SSAB and self-enhancement, and supported the viewpoint of cultural universalism that is related to self-enhancement.