Abstract:Background: Many climate mitigation policies to reduce transportation emissions have public health benefits related to ambient air pollution. However, few health analyses consider the equity implications of alternative policies. Equity can be conceptualized in many different ways that may be relevant to communities, decision-makers, and other stakeholders. Objectives: To evaluate alternative transportation emissions reduction scenarios across the northeastern United States considering population exposure reductions and multiple equity constructs. Methods: We developed four quantitative indicators reflecting equity constructs that aligned with stakeholder perspectives, including racial/ethnic exposure inequities, proportion of benefits in environmental justice communities, distribution of benefits among participating states, and rural/urban share of benefits. We analyzed numerous transportation emissions reduction scenarios for directly emitted fine particulate matter (primary PM2.5) covering 12 Northeast states and the District of Columbia. We used the Community Multiscale Air Quality model with the decoupled direct method to estimate the reduction in population-weighted primary PM2.5 exposure and the impact on equity for each scenario. Results: Scenarios that yielded greater reductions in population-weighted primary PM2.5 exposure generally emphasized emissions reductions in urban areas or states with large urban centers, with a more than threefold difference in benefits across scenarios. The higher exposure-benefit scenarios typically also had greater reductions in racial/ethnic exposure inequities but led to higher between-state or rural/urban inequality. Scenarios that targeted uniform percentage emission reductions from light or heavy-duty trucks best addressed rural/urban inequalities but led to the smallest reductions in racial/ethnic inequity. Conclusion: There are intrinsic tradeoffs among equity constructs, where focusing resources on distributing benefits across states or between urban and rural populations could come at the expense of less reduction in racial/ethnic exposure inequities or in environmental justice communities. Future health benefits analyses should incorporate multiple equity indicators that reflect different stakeholder perspectives and articulate the underlying constructs and tradeoffs.

Environmental injustice in America: Racial disparities in exposure to air pollution health damages from freight trucking

Air pollution impacts from warehousing in the United States uncovered with satellite data

The health, climate, and equity benefits of freight truck electrification in the United States

Increasing Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Ambient Air Pollution-Attributable Morbidity and Mortality in the United States

Health benefits of decreases in on-road transportation emissions in the United States from 2008 to 2017

An environmental justice analysis of air pollution emissions in the United States from 1970 to 2010

The contribution of motor vehicle emissions to ambient fine particulate matter public health impacts in New York City: a health burden assessment

Quantifying Disparities in Air Pollution Exposures across the United States Using Home and Work Addresses

Local inequities in the relative production of and exposure to vehicular air pollution in Los Angeles

A comparison of population-level exposure and equity tradeoffs across strategies to reduce fine particulate matter emissions from transportation sources in the northeastern US

Estimating Intra-Urban Inequities in PM2.5-Attributable Health Impacts: A Case Study for Washington, DC

Global trade, local impacts: lessons from California on health impacts and environmental justice concerns for residents living near freight rail yards

Spatial Analysis of Intra-Urban Air Pollution Disparities through an Environmental Justice Lens: A Case Study of Philadelphia, PA

Persistent Environmental Injustice due to Brake and Tire Wear Emissions and Heavy-Duty Trucks in Future California Zero-Emission Fleets

Corridor-Level Impacts of Battery-Electric Heavy-Duty Trucks and the Effects of Policy in the United States

Fine Particulate Air Pollution from Electricity Generation in the US: Health Impacts by Race, Income, and Geography

Ethnoracial Disparities in Nitrogen Dioxide Pollution in the United States: Comparing Data Sets from Satellites, Models, and Monitors

Air pollution exposure disparities across US population and income groups

PM 2.5 exposure disparities persist despite strict vehicle emissions controls in California

Sociodemographic and geographic variation in mortality attributable to air pollution in the United States

PM2.5 exposure disparities persist despite strict vehicle emissions controls in California