HORIZONTAL WATERMILL CHRONOLOGIES BASED ON 14 C DATING OF ORGANICS IN MORTARS: A CASE STUDY FROM JARASH, JORDAN

David Boyer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/rdc.2024.24
IF: 6.324
2024-03-12
Radiocarbon
Abstract:Horizontal watermills in the southern Levant have proved difficult to date. This study investigates the use of radiocarbon ( 14 C) dating of various organic carbon fractions in structural mortars and carbonate deposits to identify terminus post quem (TPQ) construction dates for seven arubah watermills and two chute watermills in northern Jordan. Dating results from the various organic fractions are discussed in the contexts of carbon fraction integrity and mortar type. The arubah watermill construction dates fall into two chronological groups. Four arubah watermills have Middle Islamic (late 12th to early 14th century AD) construction dates based on macrocharcoal and bulk organic fraction ages, whereas the bulk organic fraction ages of two earlier arubah watermills straddle the Byzantine-Early Islamic transition. Their possible fifth to seventh-century construction dates are among the earliest in the southern Levant. Limited 14 C data from the chute water mills suggests that the earliest may date to the sixth–seventh century period, concurrent with the older arubah watermills. The study supports the viability of the AMS 14 C method to provide estimated TPQ construction dates for watermills, providing caution is exercised. Short-lived macrocharcoals have the highest integrity but are subject to severe sample loss during pretreatment. 14 C ages from humic and humin fractions in earthen mortars are influenced by "old carbon" contamination, possibly a soil reservoir effect, and are centuries older than the probable construction date. Attention is drawn to the potential use of arubah carbonate deposits as proxy records of water flow, watermill use, and hydroclimate.
geochemistry & geophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the difficult problem of accurately determining the construction age of horizontal water mills in the southern Levant region. Specifically, by using radiocarbon (^{14}C) dating techniques, the author analyzes organic matter and carbonate sediments in nine horizontal water mills in the Jerash area in northern Jordan to determine the construction time of these water mills. The paper pays special attention to two types of horizontal water mills: the arubah water mill (a stone tower structure with a closed vertical cylindrical pipe or arubah) and the chute water mill (a structure with an open chute). Through this method, the author aims to provide the absolute construction ages of these water mills, thereby filling the knowledge gap in the archaeological record regarding the timeline of the introduction and spread of these technologies. The main research backgrounds of the paper include: - **Historical background**: The Jerash area is located in the highlands in the northwest of Jordan, has a mild Mediterranean climate, and has been inhabited by humans since the Neolithic Age. During the Roman period, there was an extensive aqueduct network in this area, but by the early Islamic period, many aqueducts had failed due to earthquakes and lack of maintenance. - **Water mill technology**: Horizontal water mills use the energy of water flow to drive the grinding wheel, and then drive the grinding stone. According to the different water flow delivery methods, horizontal water mills can be divided into arubah - type and chute - type. - **Research area**: The research area includes the water areas of the Jerash Valley and the Majar - Tannur Valley, and these water mills are mainly supplied by surface and underground (spring) water sources. Through radiocarbon dating techniques, the author hopes to solve the following specific problems: - Determine the specific construction ages of horizontal water mills in the Jerash area. - Verify the consistency and reliability of radiocarbon dating results of different organic components (such as macro - charcoal, overall organic components). - Explore the potential of carbonate sediments as proxy records of water flow, water mill use, and hydro - climate. The solution of these problems helps to better understand the introduction time and spatial diffusion pattern of horizontal water mill technology in the southern Levant region, and how these technologies are affected by climate change and natural disasters.