COMPARISON OF VARIOUS LUMINESCENCE DATING PROCEDURES ON SEDIMENTS FROM ONE OF THE STRATH TERRACES OF THE YELLOW RIVER IN THE JINSHAAN CANYON
Yan Yanyan,Zhang Jiafu,Hu Gang,Zhou Liping
DOI: https://doi.org/10.11928/j.issn.1001-7410.2018.03.05
2018-01-01
Abstract:The Yellow River flows along the northern and northeastern and borders of the Ordos Plateau,and cuts through the eastern plateau at an average elevation of 1050 m to 1500 m above sea level(a.s.l.)from north to south.Results in the formation of the Jinshaan Canyon limited to the reach from Lamawan to Yumenkou,and the canyon links the Weihe graben and the Hetao graben in the middle reach of the Yellow River.A series of strath terraces have been developed along the banks of the canyon,and the fluvial terrace deposits are covered by loess with various thicknesses.It is one of the key issues for its geomorphological studies to determine the accurate formation age of the terraces.Although there have been a lot of investigations about dating of the Yellow River terraces,especially for luminescence dating,the comparison of reliabilities of the ages obtained using different methods is rare.In this study,a typical strath terrace of the river in the Heiyukou area(38°32′36.34″N,110°54′25.88″E) in the Jinshaan Canyon was identified at least five strath terraces on the two banks of the Yellow River.The second terraces was selected to be investigated in this study.The elevation of the river course in this area is about 770 m a.s.l.,and the elevation of the strath surface is about 12.6 m above the modern channel.The terrace deposits which are 9.66 m in thick,are exposed in the river cliff and a sandpit,and can be divided into four layers.Five samples(samples HYK16-1～5) were collected from the fresh profile.About 12.6 m thick bedrock is exposed,which mainly comprises Triassic sandstone with a horizontal bedding.Note that the surface of the bedrock is loose because of weathering.A bedrock sample was also collected for testing its luminescence properties.In order to assess the bleaching of the fluvial deposits,a modern sample(HYK16-6) was taken from a sidebar at the foot of the river cliff.The modern sample is most likely deposited during the last flood.All six samples for luminescence dating using a single-aliquot regenerative-dose (OSL-SAR) protocol on fine-grained (FG) and coarse-grained (CG) quartz,and a multiple-elevated-temperature post-IR IRSL(MET-pIRIR)procedure on CG K-feldspar.A modern sample was also tested for its residual dose using two thermally transferred OSL(TT-OSL)procedure with different regenerative dose.The results show that the fine and coarse quartz grains have different luminescence properties due to their different sources,especially for some coarse quartz grains derived from the surface materials of local weathered sandstone bedrock.The fine quartz grains exhibit more fast component,higher saturation dose(＞2000 Gy)and more thermal stability,which make them more suitable than the CG grains for luminescence dating.Although a large residual dose of the FG grains from the modern sample was detected,the FG quartz SAR-OSL ages are in stratigraphic order.This implies that the FG quartz SAR-OSL ages are more reliable.The CG quartz SAR-OSL ages are large scatter,and not stratigraphically consistent,suggesting that these ages are not reliable.Based on the FG SAR-OSL ages,the studied terrace was determined to 64.7±2.5 ka.The CG quartz thermally-transferred OSL(TT-OSL)and CG K-feldspar MET-pIRIR signals from the modern sample are very poorly bleached at deposition.The TT-OSL De value of up to 380 Gy for CG quartz is much larger than its corresponding SAR-OSL De value.The residual TT-OSL dose of the modern sample is related to the measured procedures and the size of the regenerate doses used.And the MET-pIRIR ages(106～ 148 ka) obtained for the terrace samples are much larger than their quartz SAR-OSL ages (50～70 ka)and beyond the upper age limit of the overlying Malan loess(71 ka).This study implies that when dating other Yellow River terraces both fine and coarse quartz fractions should be used in order to obtain reliable ages,and the reliability of FG and CG quartz OSL ages obtained must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.Caution is needed when dating the Yellow River terraces with the MET-pIRIR and TT-OSL procedures.