Transubstantiation Through the Lens of Spacetime Substantivalism
Travis Dumsday,Travis DumsdayTravis Dumsday is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Concordia University of Edmonton. He is the author of Dispositionalism and the Metaphysics of Science (Cambridge University Press,2019),and Assisted Suicide in Canada: Moral,Legal,and Policy Considerations (University of British Columbia Press,2021).
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14746700.2023.2293621
2024-01-15
Theology and Science
Abstract:The doctrine of transubstantiation (as understood by Aquinas and much subsequent Roman Catholic theology) involves the counter-intuitive claim that accidents can come to exist independently of any substance. In particular, the spatial dimensions of bread and wine can come to exist independently. I point out that a key idea that motivated this claim was an aspect of mediaeval philosophy of nature: namely, relationism about space. I argue that if relationism is dropped in favour of substantivalism, then room is made for a model of transubstantiation which needn't involve an implausible commitment to independently existing accidents.
history & philosophy of science