Abstract:How does revenue diversification shape the budgetary solvency of city governments? Previous studies informed by the public choice/fiscal illusion perspective suggest that diversification leads to unsustainable government expansion and budgetary imbalance. In contrast, the organizational adaptation/modern portfolio theory suggests that diversification enables government to prepare for external fiscal shocks. We use different measures of revenue diversification and rely on audited financial information to develop general fund‐based and government‐wide budgetary solvency measures for more than 500 midsized and large cities in the United States from 2006 to 2012. Addressing omitted variable bias, the results of the econometric analyses indicate that the type of diversification matters. Specifically, diversifying to non‐tax sources improves budgetary solvency as indicated by higher government‐wide operating ratio and reserves, whereas diversifying within the tax structure produces the opposite effects. The contradictory results point to the need to rethink current theories of diversification, which do not recognize the different ways that revenue structures can be broadened, and how these produce distinct effects on fiscal performance. We lay out the critical first step in clarifying and further developing a more nuanced theory by proposing three causal mechanisms outlining the pathways through which the types of diversification can influence budget outcomes. • This study examines the relationship between tax and non‐tax revenue diversification and government‐wide budgetary solvency (structural budget balance). It is the first in the revenue diversification literature to consider the total revenues and costs of operating government and incorporates a broader base of tax and non‐tax revenue sources including utilities. • The results suggest that increased reliance on non‐tax revenue sources, such as charges and fees, improves budgetary solvency. • In contrast, we find evidence that increased diversification of tax instruments leads to poor budget outcomes. • When financial managers and policymakers are considering adopting a new revenue source or expanding a current revenue stream, from a budgetary solvency standpoint, non‐tax sources may be advantageous. This study examines the relationship between tax and non‐tax revenue diversification and government‐wide budgetary solvency (structural budget balance). It is the first in the revenue diversification literature to consider the total revenues and costs of operating government and incorporates a broader base of tax and non‐tax revenue sources including utilities. The results suggest that increased reliance on non‐tax revenue sources, such as charges and fees, improves budgetary solvency. In contrast, we find evidence that increased diversification of tax instruments leads to poor budget outcomes. When financial managers and policymakers are considering adopting a new revenue source or expanding a current revenue stream, from a budgetary solvency standpoint, non‐tax sources may be advantageous.

Analyzing the causality between revenues and expenditures in Spanish municipalities and its policy implications

Determinants of local government deficit: evidence from Spanish municipalities

Public Debt in the Spanish Municipalities: Drivers and Policy Proposals

Does the gender dissimilarity of female mayors with their political government team affect municipalities' budgets? Evidence from Spain

Analysing credit risk in large local governments: an empirical study in Spain

The Impact of Soft Budget Constraint on the Fiscal Co-responsibility of the Autonomous Communities in Spain: The Case of Extraordinary Liquidity Funds (2012-2019)

Do independent fiscal institutions cause better fiscal outcomes in the European Union?

Secession of municipalities and economies of scale: Evidence from Brazil

Revisiting the theory of revenue diversification: Insights from an empirical analysis of municipal budgetary solvency

Delving into public-expenditure elasticity: Evidence from a National Health Service acute-care hospital network

Sustainability of Local Public Finances from the Perspective of Territorial Disparities in the Rural Areas of Romania

Behind the budget: analysing the factors driving sustainable urban development financing in Spain

Local tax interaction and endogenous spatial weights based on quality of life

The impact of population size on the risk of local government default

Vertical consolidation and financial sustainability: evidence from English local government

Local government spending and mental health: Untangling the impacts using a dynamic modelling approach

Fiscal Balance Factors of the Local Government: Panel Data Evidence from OECD Countries

The determinants of the financial distress of Italian municipalities: How much is it due to inadequate resources?

Scaling behavior of public procurement activity

Valeria Merlo discussion of: Natural resource revenues and municipal finance

Nicola Limodio discussion of: Natural resource revenues and municipal finance