Abstract:This work presents a comparison of three performance-based seismic design methods (PBSD) as applied to plane steel frames having eccentric braces (EBFs) and buckling restrained braces (BRBFs). The first method uses equivalent modal damping ratios (�k)referring to an equivalent multi-degree-of-freedom (MDOF) linear system, which retains the mass, the elastic stiffness and responds in the same way as the original non-linear MDOF system. The second method employs modal strength reduction factors (�𝑘) resulting from the corresponding modal damping ratios. Contrary to the behavior factors of code based design methods, both �k and �k account for the first few modes of significance and incorporate target deformation metrics like inter-storey drift ratio (IDR) and local ductility as well as structural characteristics like structural natural period, and soil types. Explicit empirical expressions of �k and �k, recently presented by the present authors elsewhere, are also provided here for reasons of completeness and easy reference. The third method, developed here by the authors, is based on a hybrid force/displacement (HFD) seismic design scheme, since it combines the force-base design (FBD) method with the displacement-based design (DBD) method. According to this method, seismic design is accomplished by using a behavior factor (qh), empirically expressed in terms of the global ductility of the frame, which takes into account both non-structural and structural deformation metrics. These expressions for qh are obtained through extensive parametric studies involving non-linear dynamic analysis (NLDA) of 98 frames, subjected to 100 far-fault ground motions that correspond to four soil types of Eurocode 8. Furthermore, these factors can be used in conjunction with an elastic acceleration design spectrum for seismic design purposes. Finally, a comparison among the above three seismic design methods and the Eurocode 8 method is conducted with the aid of non-linear dynamic analyses via representative numerical examples, involving plane steel EBFs and BRBFs.

A Seismic Design Method for Reinforced Concrete Moment Resisting Frames Using Modal Strength Reduction Factors

Modal Strength Reduction Factors for Seismic Design of Plane Steel Braced Frames

Modal Strength Reduction Factors for Seismic Design of Steel Moment Resisting Frames

Seismic design of steel structures using modal strength reduction (behavior) factors

Towards a Seismic Design Method for Plane Steel Frames Using Equivalent Modal Damping Ratios

Deformation Dependent Equivalent Modal Damping Ratios for the Performance-Based Seismic Design of Plane R/C Structures

Modal behavior factors for the performance-based seismic design of R/C wall-frame dual systems and infilled-MRFs

13.15: Seismic Design of Steel Moment Resisting Frames: Modal Strength Reduction Factors Including Strength Deterioration and Panel Zone Effects

Seismic Design of Plane Steel MRFS, EBFS and BRBFS by Improved Direct Displacement-Based Design Method

Prediction of Seismic Inelastic Displacement Profiles of R/C Moment Resisting Frames

A Direct Displacement-Based Seismic Design Method Using a MDOF Equivalent System: Application to R/C Framed Structures

A Hybrid Force/displacement Seismic Design Method for Reinforced Concrete Moment Resisting Frames

Assessment of Seismic Inelastic Displacement Profiles of Steel MRFs by Means of Modal Behavior Factors

Case Study on the Seismic Performance of Reinforced Concrete Intermediate Moment Frames Using ACI Design Provisions

A Comparison of Three Performance-Based Seismic Design Methods for Plane Steel Braced Frames

Application of the Hybrid Force/Displacement (hfd) Seismic Design Method to Composite Steel/Concrete Plane Frames

A Hybrid Seismic Design Method for Steel Irregular Space Moment Resisting Frames

Multi-modal and multi-level structure-specific spectral intensity measures for seismic evaluation of reinforced concrete frames

A New Seismic Design Method for Steel Structures

Seismic Design of Plane Steel Frames Using Advanced Methods of Analysis

The equivalent modal damping concept and its use in seismic design of steel structures