Abstract:(1) Background: Ultrashort high-energy laser pulses may cause interaction mechanisms, including photodisruption and plasma-induced ablation in the medium. It is not always easy to distinguish between these two processes, as both interaction mechanisms rely on plasma generation and overlap. The purpose of this paper is to discuss prominent cavitation bubble models describing photodisruption and plasma-induced ablation and to explore their nature for different threshold energies. This exploration will help to better distinguish the two interaction mechanisms. As a second aim, we present an alternative model for the low-energy regime close to the laser-induced optical breakdown (LIOB) threshold, representing the phenomenological effect of the plasma-induced ablation regime. (2) Methods: The cavitation bubble models for photodisruption and plasma-induced ablation were used to calculate the bubble radius for a series of threshold energies (ETh = 30, 50, 70, and 300 nJ) that loosely represent commercial systems currently used in ultrashort-pulse tissue ablation. Taking a photodisruption model coefficient commonly used in the literature, the root mean square error between the two interaction models was minimized using the generalized reduced gradient fitting method to calculate the optimum scaling factors for the plasma model. The refined models with optimized coefficients were compared for a range of pulse and threshold energies. (3) Results: For low ETh (30, 50, and 70 nJ), the plasma-induced ablation model dominates for low energies that are close to the threshold energy. The photodisruption model dominates for high energies that are well above the threshold energy. At very high pulse energies, for all the simulated cases, the photodisruption model transitions and crosses over to the plasma-induced ablation model. The cross-over points from which the photodisruption model dominates tend to be reduced for larger ETh. A new universally applicable model for plasma-induced ablation has been hypothesized that considers the cavitation bubble volume and potentially better explains the bubble dynamics during intrastromal processes. (4) Conclusions: This theoretical exploration and the comparison of the outcomes to empirical data substantiate that inadvertently using the photodisruption model to explain the cavitation bubble dynamics for the entire spectrum of pulse energies and laser systems might provide erroneous estimates of cavitation bubble sizes. A reliable estimate of the true size (the maximum radius) of the cavitation bubble can be reasonably retrieved as the maximum predicted size from the fit of the photodisruption model and the newly proposed plasma-induced ablation model at any given pulse energy.

Quantitative understanding of skin tissue ablation from UV to NIR with a new plasma model

Modeling of Skin Tissue Ablation by Nanosecond Pulses from Ultraviolet to Near-Infrared and Comparison with Experimental Results

Surface Ablation of Porcine Skin Tissue Using Nanosecond Laser Pulses at 1064 Nm

Ultraviolet Versus Infrared: Effects of Ablation Laser Wavelength on the Expansion of Laser-Induced Plasma into One-Atmosphere Argon Gas

Improved thermal model and its application in UV high-power pulsed laser ablation of metal target

Efficient Use Of Q-Switched Lasers In The Treatment Of Cutaneous Lesions.

Numerical Analysis of the Temperature Field in Skin-tissue by High Power Nd∶YAG Pulses Laser

A Refined Model for Ablation Through Cavitation Bubbles with Ultrashort Pulse Lasers

Laser Plasma Induced Ablation in Cells of Eye Tissue

An Experimental Study on Low-Temperature Plasma Tissue Ablation and Its Thermal Effect

Numerical simulation of heat transfer properties of skin tissue acted on repetitive laser irradiation

Mechanism Study of Porcine Skin Ablation by Nanosecond Laser Pulses at 1064, 532, 266, and 213 Nm

Study of Femtosecond Ablation on Aluminum Film with 3D Two-Temperature Model and Experimental Verifications

A Model of Plasma-Biofilm and Plasma-Tissue Interactions at Ambient Pressure

A new coupled model for laser-induced thermal ablation accounting for tissue water vaporization

Numerical Simulation and Experimental Study on Thermal Damage in Invitro Human Skin-tissue by High-Intensity Laser

A theoretical model considering the photochemical and photothermal behavior of arc radiation-induced gassing materials ablation

Theoretical analysis on thermal treatment of skin with repetitive pulses

Calculation of Thermal Effect in Skin-Tissue Induced by Laser

A Simple Model for Electron Temperature and Penetration Depth in Interaction of Ultra-Short Laser Pulses with Solid Targets

Observations of in vivo laser tissue ablation in animal models with different chromophores on the skin and modulating duration per laser exposure