Abstract:Conceptual design is a pivotal stage of new product development in manufacturing industries. Since multiple design alternatives are put forward at this stage, developing advanced evaluation methods is of great importance. Existing methods adopt additive models to integrate evaluation data. They face some inconsistency issues, e.g. inconsistency in the independent assumption and interdependent data, since evaluation criteria are interactional. Fuzzy measure that replaces the additivity with monotonicity has enabled advances in addressing such issues. This work proposes a two-additive fuzzy measure-based information integration approach to product design alternative evaluation for the first time. The evaluation data given by experts are in the form of intuitionistic linguistic numbers. They are more in accordance with the thinking habits of experts because the hesitation degree in linguistic assessment can be revealed. In order to reduce the subjective bias, the decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory method combining with grey relational analysis is applied to adjust evaluation data. Then monotonous two-additive fuzzy measure is identified by nonlinear programming using these data. It makes a good trade-off between computational complexity and presentation capability. Hence, evaluation data can be integrated by non-additive Choquet integral for ranking design alternatives. In comparison to additive model-based methods, the extra effect on the simultaneous satisfaction of criteria can be effectively revealed by the proposed approach. And the robustness of it is demonstrated by the sensitivity analysis. A case study on an elevator's design alternative evaluation is conducted to illustrate the feasibility and practicability of the proposed approach.

A Method for Selecting Product Design Alternatives Considering Index Expectation

A Probabilistic Approach for Extracting Design Preferences from Design Team Discussion

Two-additive Fuzzy Measure-Based Information Integration Approach to Product Design Alternative Evaluation

An Approach to the Extraction of Preference-Related Information from Design Team Language

A Comparison of Formal Methods for Evaluating the Language of Preference in Engineering Design

An Index-weight Determination Method for Target Syste m of Evaluation on Treatment Installation of Environmental Pollution

Decision-making Model of Product Design Based on Principal Component Analysis

Prospect Theory Model for Multiple Criteria Decision Making Alternative with Interval Number

Selecting the Best Simulated Design with the Expected Opportunity Cost Bound.

Decision Model for Product Design Based on Fuzzy Synthetic Evaluation Method

Product Variant Design Based on Design Parameter Estimation

Mass Customization and Variety

Construction of Product Module Based on Interpretive Structure Modeling and Its Optimization

Utilize Fuzzy Delphi and Analytic Network Process to Construct Consumer Product Design Evaluation Indicators

Method for Determining the Index Evaluation and Weighting for the Transition Period of Electricity Retail Market by Considering the Correlation of Indexes

Collaborative evaluation method for product concept based on Choquet integral and evidence theory

An Optimal Opportunity Cost Selection Procedure for A Fixed Number of Designs

A Novel Decision-Making Approach for Product Design Evaluation Using Improved TOPSIS and GRP Method Under Picture Fuzzy Set

An integrated AHP and VIKOR for design concept evaluation based on rough number

Two-Stage Three-Way Enhanced Multi-Criteria Classification Optimization for Risk-Averse Product Design Programming

Information-intensive design solution evaluator combined with multiple design and preference information in product design