Abstract:The process of selecting among design alternatives is an important activity in the early stages of design. A designer is said to express design preferences when assigning priorities to a set of possible design choices. However, the assignment of preferences becomes more challenging on both a practical and theoretical level when performed by a group. This paper presents a probabilistic approach for estimating a team's overall preference-related information known as preferential probabilities that extracts information from the natural language used in team discussion transcripts without aggregation of individual team member opinions. Assessment of the method is conducted by surveying a design team to obtain quantitative ratings of alternatives. Two different approaches are applied to convert these ratings into values that may be compared to the results of transcript analysis: the application of a modified Logit model and simulation based on the principle of maximum entropy. The probabilistic approach proposed in the paper represents how likely a choice is to be "most preferred" by a design team over a given period of time. A preliminary design selection experiment was conducted as an illustrative case example of the method. Correlations were found between the preferential probabilities estimated from transcripts and those computed from the surveyed preferences. The proposed methods may provide a formal way to understand and represent informal, unstructured design information using a low overhead information extraction method.

Product Variant Design Based on Design Parameter Estimation

Research On Product Variant Design With Uncertainty Information

Product Optimal Variant Design Based on Uniform Design

Research & Realization on the Variant Design of Mechanical Products Based on Parametric Techniques

Research & Realization on the Variant Design of Product Based on Bidirectional Principle

Study on Goodness Evaluation Method in Extenics and Its Application in the Variant Design

Research on Product Structure Model for Variant Design

A Probabilistic Approach for Extracting Design Preferences from Design Team Discussion

Configuration product variant design for mass customization

Product Variant Design Based on Tabular Layouts of Article Characteristics

An Approach to the Extraction of Preference-Related Information from Design Team Language

Research technology and application of configuration product variant design for mass customization

Research on Method of Product Modeling Faced Variant Design of Process

Variant Design for Mechanical Parts Based on Extensible Logic Theory

Fast Variational Design Based on a Master Model Generated from Part Model Series

Approach to 2D Parametric Design Based on Features

Research on Variant Design of Process Based on Part Family Variant Design

User-oriented product conceptual design of intelligent instrument based on genetic algorithm

Research on Modeling Method of Part Family to Support Variant Design of Process

Research on Assembly Variant Design

A Model for Manufacturing Cost Estimation Based on Machining Feature