Comparison among the clinical curative effects using different 5'-nitroimidazole drugs in treating anaerobic or trichomonal vaginitis

WANG Yujuan,ZHU Meifen,LUO Dongjiao,WANG Baonan,JIANG Jinqin,YAN Jie
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0253-9934.2006.06.012
2006-01-01
Abstract:Objective To observe the clinical curative effects and side-effects of metronidazole,tinidazole and ornidazole in treating anaerobic or trichomonat vaginitis, and to analyze the susceptibility of the isolated anaerobes and trichomonads to the three drugs. Methods Based on the bacteriological and parasitological laboratory examina- tion results, 290 anaerobic vaginitis patients and 62 trichomonal vaginitis patients were randomly divided into three groups treated with metronidazole, tinidazole and ornidazole, respectively. Doubling plate dilution method was ap- plied to determine the minimal inhibition concentrations(MIC) of the three drugs in inhibiting the anaerobic iso- lates, and the same dilution method was performed to detect the minimal parasiticidal concentrations (MPC) of the three drugs in killing the trichomonal isolates. Results The effective rate (54. 6%) of metronidazole in anaerobic vaginitis was remarkably lower than those of tinidazole (68. 8, P<0. 05) and ornidazole (74. 2%, P<0.01), but they showed no significant difference between the curative rates of tinidazole and ornidazole(P>0. 05). The curative rates of the three drugs in trichomonal vaginitis were 90. 5%, 100% and 100%, respec- tively with no significant differences among the curative rates (P>0.05). The total side-effect rate of metron- idazole in the treated patients was obviously higher than those of tinidazole (P<0.01) and ornidazole (P<0. 01), but those of tinidazole and ornidazole were similar (P>0. 05). The MIC_(90) values of metronidazole, tinidazole and ornidazole against 266 Gram-negative anaerobic isolates were 4~8, 1~2 and 1~2μg/mL, and 32~64, 8~32 and 8~16μg/mL for 261 Gram-positive anaerobic ones, respectively. The MPC values of met- ronidazole, tinidazole and ornidazole in killing triehomonads were 25, 5 and 5μg/mL, respectively. Conclusion The outcome of comparison with metronidazole, tinidazole and ornidazole for anaerobic vaginitis shows higher cura- tive effects and lower side-effects, but metronidazole is much cheaper. The clinical anaerobic strains have much higher resistance to metronidazole. All three drugs dislay stronger activities against the Gram-negative anaerobes than the Gram-positive ones, however, the gram-negative anaerobes still show higher sensitivity to ornidazole.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?