Abstract:The rational use of materials is the key to urban sustainable development. The research of urban metabolism in the field of industrial ecology can provide effective insights for this goal. Considering the time lag of urban metabolism reviews in earlier years and the one-sidedness of reviews in recent years, it is urgent to review urban metabolism studies from more perspectives in recent years. In order to assist in the purpose of timely forming comprehensive summaries of research experience and effective guidance for future research, this study provides a focused review of urban metabolism from the perspective of methods that have been and should be concerned. Firstly, according to the keyword co-occurrence, we identified the two methods that have attracted the most attention in urban metabolism research, material flow analysis and ecological network analysis, as well as factor analysis that has been expected to promote the practical application of urban metabolism research. Then we further collected relevant literature of these three concerns, sorted out the current achievements and shortcomings of them, providing a basis for the future efforts. The results show that material flow analysis has been applied to many cases at different scales and has a general tendency to focus on specific components of the metabolic system. Ecological network analysis has realized the simulation of internal process on the basis of accounting, and opened the "black box" of urban metabolism the aspect of process. Urban metabolic factor analysis has been paid more attention to, so as to better serve urban planning and design. However, there are relatively few prediction studies on setting scenarios based on the results of factor analysis, which limits the application of research to a certain extent. Based on summarizing the current research status, this review proposed a research route of "flow quantification - network simulation - scenario prediction", to provide an efficient and convenient idea for future work about urban metabolism.

Urban metabolism process based on emergy synthesis: a case study of Beijing

Analysis of Emergy Dynamice in Beijing Urban Ecosystem

Uncovering Driving Forces on Urban Metabolism—a Case of Shenyang

Measurement and evaluation of the metabolic capacity of an urban ecosystem

The structure, evolution and sustainability of urban socio-economic system.

Ecological Economic Evaluation Based on Emergy As Embodied Cosmic Exergy: A Historical Study for the Beijing Urban Ecosystem 1978–2004

Urban Metabolism of Three Cities in Jing-Jin-Ji Urban Agglomeration, China: Using the Musiasem Approach

Ecological accounting and evaluation of urban economy: Taking Beijing city as the case

Correlation and synergy analysis of urban economy–energy–environment system—A case study of Beijing

Gearing Urban Metabolism toward the Carbon Neutrality Target: A Case Study of Hebei Province, China

Ecological Evaluation of Beijing Economy Based on Emergy Indices

How Does Electricity Supply Mode Affect Energy-Water-emissions Nexus in Urban Energy System? Evidence from Energy Transformation in Beijing, China

Emergy-based comparative analysis of urban ecosystem in Beijing, Tianjin and Tangshan

Progress in urban metabolism research and hotspot analysis based on CiteSpace analysis

Urban metabolism of megacities: A comparative analysis of Shanghai, Tokyo, London and Paris to inform low carbon and sustainable development pathways

Empirical Research on Sustainable Evaluation System for China's Urban Energy

Embodied Energy Consumption and Carbon Emissions Evaluation for Urban Industrial Structure Optimization

Tracking urban metabolism flows through the lifecycle of buildings, infrastructure, and durable goods at material, product, and sector levels

A review of a series of effective methods in urban metabolism: Material flow, ecological network and factor analysis

Understanding Resilience of Urban Food-Energy-water Nexus System: Insights from an Ecological Network Analysis of Megacity Beijing

Urban metabolism: A review of research methodologies